Санта действительно существует? Философское расследование. Эрик Каплан

Рассел (1872–1970) – британский философ, математик и общественный деятель. Один из главных основателей английского неореализма и неопозитивизма. Прим. ред.

      4

      Альфред Тарский (1901–1983) – польско-американский математик, логик, основатель формальной теории истинности. Прим. ред.

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