“But what is he doing with Mr. Dowden?” I asked.
She lifted her eyebrows. “Why—taking him for a drive, I suppose.”
“No. I mean—how do they happen to be together?”
“Why shouldn’t they be? They’re old friends—”
“They are!” And, in answer to her look of surprise, I explained that I had begun to speak of Beasley at Mrs. Apperthwaite’s, and described the abruptness with which Dowden had changed the subject.
“I see,” my cousin nodded, comprehendingly. “That’s simple enough. George Dowden didn’t want you to talk of Beasley there. I suppose it may have been a little embarrassing for everybody—especially if Ann Apperthwaite heard you.”
“Ann? That’s Miss Apperthwaite? Yes; I was speaking directly to her. Why shouldn’t she have heard me? She talked of him herself a little later—and at some length, too.”
“She did!” My cousin stopped rocking, and fixed me with her glittering eye. “Well, of all!”
“Is it so surprising?”
The lady gave her boat to the waves again. “Ann Apperthwaite thinks about him still!” she said, with something like vindictiveness. “I’ve always suspected it. She thought you were new to the place and didn’t know anything about it all, or anybody to mention it to. That’s it!”
“I’m still new to the place,” I urged, “and still don’t know anything about it all.”
“They used to be engaged,” was her succinct and emphatic answer.
I found it but too illuminating. “Oh, oh!” I cried. “I was an innocent, wasn’t I?”
“I’m glad she does think of him,” said my cousin. “It serves her right. I only hope he won’t find it out, because he’s a poor, faithful creature; he’d jump at the chance to take her back—and she doesn’t deserve him.”
“How long has it been,” I asked, “since they used to be engaged?”
“Oh, a good while—five or six years ago, I think—maybe more; time skips along. Ann Apperthwaite’s no chicken, you know.” (Such was the lady’s expression.) “They got engaged just after she came home from college, and of all the idiotically romantic girls—”
“But she’s a teacher,” I interrupted, “of mathematics.”
“Yes.” She nodded wisely. “I always thought that explained it: the romance is a reaction from the algebra. I never knew a person connected with mathematics or astronomy or statistics, or any of those exact things, who didn’t have a crazy streak in ’em somewhere. They’ve got to blow off steam and be foolish to make up for putting in so much of their time at hard sense. But don’t you think that I dislike Ann Apperthwaite. She’s always been one of my best friends; that’s why I feel at liberty to abuse her—and I always will abuse her when I think how she treated poor David Beasley.”
“How did she treat him?”
“Threw him over out of a clear sky one night, that’s all. Just sent him home and broke his heart; that is, it would have been broken if he’d had any kind of disposition except the one the Lord blessed him with—just all optimism and cheerfulness and make-the-best-of-it-ness! He’s never cared for anybody else, and I guess he never will.”
“What did she do it for?”
“Nothing!” My cousin shot the indignant word from her lips. “Nothing in the wide world!”
“But there must have been—”
“Listen to me,” she interrupted, “and tell me if you ever heard anything queerer in your life. They’d been engaged—Heaven knows how long—over two years; probably nearer three—and always she kept putting it off; wouldn’t begin to get ready, wouldn’t set a day for the wedding. Then Mr. Apperthwaite died, and left her and her mother stranded high and dry with nothing to live on. David had everything in the world to give her—and still she wouldn’t! And then, one day, she came up here and told me she’d broken it off. Said she couldn’t stand it to be engaged to David Beasley another minute!”
“But why?”
“Because”—my cousin’s tone was shrill with her despair of expressing the satire she would have put into it—“because, she said he was a man of no imagination!”
“She still says so,” I remarked, thoughtfully.
“Then it’s time she got a little imagination herself!” snapped my companion. “David Beasley’s the quietest man God has made, but everybody knows what he is! There are some rare people in this world that aren’t all talk; there are some still rarer ones that scarcely ever talk at all—and David Beasley’s one of them. I don’t know whether it’s because he can’t talk, or if he can and hates to; I only know he doesn’t. And I’m glad of it, and thank the Lord he’s put a few like that into this talky world! David Beasley’s smile is better than acres of other people’s talk. My Providence! Wouldn’t anybody, just to look at him, know that he does better than talk? He thinks! The trouble with Ann Apperthwaite was that she was too young to see it. She was so full of novels and poetry and dreaminess and highfalutin nonsense she couldn’t see anything as it really was. She’d study her mirror, and see such a heroine of romance there that she just couldn’t bear to have a fiance who hadn’t any chance of turning out to be the crown-prince of Kenosha in disguise! At the very least, to suit her he’d have had to wear a ‘well-trimmed Vandyke’ and coo sonnets in the gloaming, or read On a Balcony to her by a red lamp.
“Poor David! Outside of his law-books, I don’t believe he’s ever read anything but Robinson Crusoe and the Bible and Mark Twain. Oh, you should have heard her talk about it!—‘I couldn’t bear it another day,’ she said, ‘I couldn’t stand it! In all the time I’ve known him I don’t believe he’s ever asked me a single question—except when he asked if I’d marry him. He never says anything—never speaks at all!’ she said. ‘You don’t know a blessing when you see it,’ I told her. ‘Blessing!’ she said. ‘There’s nothing in the man! He has no depths! He hasn’t any more imagination than the chair he sits and sits and sits in! Half the time he answers what I say to him by nodding and saying ‘um-hum,’ with that same old foolish, contented smile of his. I’d have gone mad if it had lasted any longer!’ I asked her if she thought married life consisted very largely of conversations between husband and wife; and she answered that even married life ought to have some poetry in it. ‘Some romance,’ she said, ‘some soul! And he just comes and sits,’ she said, ‘and sits and sits and sits and sits! And I can’t bear it any longer, and I’ve told him so.’”
“Poor Mr. Beasley,” I said.
“I think, ‘Poor Ann Apperthwaite!’” retorted my cousin. “I’d like to know if there’s anything nicer than just to sit and sit and sit and sit with as lovely a man as that—a man who understands things, and thinks and listens and smiles—instead of everlastingly talking!”
“As it happens,” I remarked, “I’ve heard Mr. Beasley talk.”
“Why, of course he talks,” she returned, “when there’s any real use in it. And he talks to children; he’s that kind of man.”
“I meant a particular instance,” I began; meaning to see if she could give me any clew to Bill Hammersley and Simpledoria, but at that moment the gate clicked under the hand of another caller. My cousin rose to greet him; and presently I took my leave without having been able to get back upon the subject of Beasley.
Thus, once more