Martin Pippin in the Apple Orchard. Eleanor Farjeon

      In due course the change of light told them it was supper-time; and with great surprise they ate the last two loaves to the sweet accompaniment of the apples.

      "I would never have supposed," said Joscelyn, as they gathered under the central tree at the close of the meal, "that a day could pass so quickly."

      "Bait time with a diversion," said Martin, "and he will run like a donkey after a dangled carrot."

      "It has nearly been the happiest day of my life," said Joyce with a sly glance at Martin.

      "And why not quite?" said he.

      "Because it lacked a story, singer," she said demurely.

      "What can be rectified," said Martin, "must be; and the day is not yet departed, but still lingers like a listener on the threshold of night. So set the swing in motion, dear Mistress Joyce, and to its measure I will endeavor to swing my thoughts, which have till now been laggards."

      With these words he set Joyce in the swing and himself upon the branch beside it as before. And the other milkmaids climbed into their perches, rustling the fruit down from the shaken boughs; and he made of Joyce's lap a basket for the harvest. And he and each of the maids chose an apple as though supper had not been.

      "We are listening," said Joscelyn from above.

      "Not all of you," said Martin. And he looked up at Joscelyn alert on her branch, and down at Gillian prone on the steps.

      "You are here for no other purpose," said Joscelyn, "than to make them listen that will not. I would not have you think we desire to listen."

      "I think nothing but that you are the prey of circumstances," said Martin, "constrained like flowers to bear witness to that which is against all nature."

      "What do you mean by that?" said Joscelyn. "Flowers are nature itself."

      "So men have agreed," replied Martin, "yet who but men have compelled them repeatedly to assert such unnaturalnesses as that foxes wear gloves and cuckoos shoes? Out on the pretty fibbers!"

      "Please do not be angry with the flowers," said Joan.

      "How could I be?" said Martin. "The flowers must always be forgiven, because their inconsistencies lie always at men's doors. Besides, who does not love fairy-tales?"

      Then Martin kicked his heels against the tree and sang idly:

      When cuckoos fly in shoes

       And foxes run in gloves,

       Then butterflies won't go in twos

       And boys will leave their loves.

      "A silly song," said Joscelyn.

      Martin: If you say so. For my part I can never tell the difference between silliness and sense.

      Jane: Then how can a good song be told from a bad? You must go by something.

      Martin: I go by the sound. But since Mistress Joscelyn pronounces my song silly, I can only suppose she has seen cuckoos flying in shoes.

      Joscelyn: You are always supposing nonsense. Who ever heard of cuckoos flying in shoes?

      Jane: Or of foxes running in gloves?

      Joan: Or of butterflies going in ones?

      Martin: Or of boys—

      Joscelyn: I have frequently seen butterflies going in ones, foolish Joan. And the argument was not against butterflies, but cuckoos.

      Martin: And their shoes. Please, dear Mistress Joan, do not look so downcast, nor you, dear Mistress Joscelyn, so vexed. Let us see if we cannot turn a more sensible song upon this theme.

      And he sang—

      Cuckoo Shoes aren't cuckoos' shoes,

       They're shoes which cuckoos never don;

       And cuckoo nests aren't cuckoos' nests,

       But other birds' for a moment gone;

       And nothing that the cuckoo has

       But he does make a mock upon.

       For even when the cuckoo sings

       He only says what isn't true—

       When happy lovers first swore oaths

       An artful cuckoo called and flew,

       Yes! and when lovers weep like dew

       The teasing cuckoo laughs Cuckoo!

       What need for tears? Cuckoo, cuckoo!

      As Martin ended, Gillian raised herself upon an elbow, and looked no more into the green grass, but across the green duckpond.

      "The second song seems to me as irrelevant as the first," said Joscelyn, "but I observe that you cuckooed so loudly as to startle our mistress out of her inattention. So if you mean to tell us another story, by all means tell it now. Not that I care, except for our extremity."

      "It is my only object to ease it," said Martin, "so bear with me as well as you may during the recital of Young Gerard."