He shook his head softly, forcing himself to think of something other than the way Holly McCay looked. It’s a good thing she isn’t a professional criminal, he thought instead, because she’s lousy at it.
Oh, she’d done her best to avoid detection, he’d give her that. The short dark-haired wig she was wearing was an effective disguise of sorts. And she’d paid cash for everything—there’d been no paper trail of credit or debit purchases to follow. No checks written, either. But she’d transferred a large sum of money from her bank in Clear Lake City south of Houston to the Cattleman’s Bank of Fort Worth, where she’d opened a new account when she moved to the Dallas–Fort Worth area. That had left a paper trail she hadn’t been able to avoid, since she’d used her own driver’s license and social security number. That was how the McCays had tracked her this far.
True, she’d varied the bank branches she’d used to withdraw funds, so no one could stake out one branch and wait for her to show up. That showed she was smart. But she’d slipped up by withdrawing cash from the Granite Gulch branch. Yeah, she’d done it only once, but it stood out in neon letters, since it was out of the pattern—all the other branches had been in Fort Worth or Dallas. And once Chris had known that, he’d searched Granite Gulch and the surrounding area for a woman with twin toddlers who’d recently moved in. No matter what color her hair was, no matter how much she tried to fade into obscurity, everyone remembered the twins. Especially eighteen-month-old identical twin boys as cute as buttons.
And Holly McCay was still driving her Ford Escape with its original Texas license plate tags registered in her name. Duh! Once he’d located a woman with twins in Rosewood, the next town over from Granite Gulch, he’d staked out the Rosewood Rooming House, where by all accounts she lived, and bingo! There was her Ford SUV with those incriminating tags.
She was registered at the rooming house using her real name, too, which had made confirmation a piece of cake. He’d almost picked up the phone to call the McCays and tell them he’d located their daughter-in-law...but he hadn’t. He wasn’t sure why. Was it because a warning light had started blinking that very first day when they turned over everything they knew about Holly’s banking transactions? Information they shouldn’t have had access to...but somehow had?
Or maybe it was the self-satisfied expression on Evalinda McCay’s face when she thought Chris wouldn’t see it, when he’d been perusing the financial reports they’d handed him and he’d glanced up unexpectedly. The expression had been wiped away almost instantly, replaced with the look of worried concern she’d worn earlier. But Chris’s instincts—which he trusted—had gone on the alert.
He’d been a private investigator for nine years, ever since he’d received his bachelor of arts degree in criminology and criminal justice from the University of Texas at Arlington. From day one he’d trusted his instincts, and they’d never steered him wrong. Only an idiot would go against his instincts in his line of work, and for all his laid-back, seemingly good-old-Texas-boy persona, Chris wasn’t an idiot.
He’d also run a credit check on the McCays the same day they’d come to see him—standard procedure for all his clients these days. He never took anyone’s word they had the wherewithal to pay him—he’d been burned once early in his career and had learned a hard lesson. The credit report on the McCays had come back with some troubling red flags. They were living beyond their means. Way beyond their means, and had done so for years, despite Angus McCay’s well-paying job as a bank president down in Houston. Even though Chris was taking this case pro bono and wouldn’t be paid except for expenses, that credit report had given him pause.
Now he was glad he hadn’t called the McCays for several reasons, not the least of which was that he knew Peg Merrill, had known her all his life. If she and Holly were friends, then Holly couldn’t be the woman the McCays had made her out to be. Peg had an unerring BS meter—she’d nailed Chris on a few things over the years—which meant Holly couldn’t have fooled Peg about the kind of woman she was. To top it off, Peg reigned supreme in one area in particular—motherhood. The worst insult in her book was to call someone a bad mother. No way would she be friends with a woman who was a bad mother.
Besides, Peg was his sister-in-law. Former sister-in-law, really, since Laura was dead. But he wasn’t going there. Not now. Sister-in-law or not, Chris didn’t want to be on Peg’s bad side. Especially not on a pro bono case he’d already been having second thoughts about.
* * *
Chris waited until Holly McCay strapped her twins into their car seats and drove away before he got out of his truck. He shrugged on his blazer to hide his shoulder holster, then settled his black Stetson on his head and ambled toward Peg’s house, determined to find out whatever he could about Holly McCay from Peg.
“Chris!” Peg exclaimed when she opened the door. “This is a surprise. Come on in.”
“Unca Chris!” Peg’s two-year-old daughter, Susan, made a beeline for Chris when he stepped inside, and he bent over to swing her up into his arms. A cacophony of barking from three dogs—one of which had been Chris’s gift to Laura not long before she died—prevented anyone from being heard for a couple of minutes, but eventually Peg’s two dogs subsided back to their rug in front of the fireplace in the family room.
Chris settled into one of the oversize recliners, still cuddling Susan against his shoulder while his other hand ruffled Wally’s fur. “Hey, boy,” he murmured, gazing down at the golden retriever Laura had adored. If his heart hadn’t already been broken when Laura died, it would have broken at losing Wally, too. Chris had given Laura the puppy thinking they’d soon be moving from their apartment into a house with a large fenced yard. But that dream house sat vacant now—Chris couldn’t bear to live there without Laura. And an apartment was no place for a growing dog, especially since Chris was rarely home. So when Peg and her husband, Joe, volunteered to adopt Wally, Chris had reluctantly accepted their offer. At least he’d still get to see Wally, he’d reasoned at the time—he was always welcome at the Merrill house.
Chris and Peg chatted about nothing much for a few minutes. About Bobby, Peg’s napping one-year-old son, who was already starting to walk. About Joe’s thriving gardening center in Granite Gulch, the Green and Grow. About Chris’s highly successful private investigation business—which he’d thrown himself into even more thoroughly after Laura’s death—and the fourth office he’d nearly decided to add in Arlington.
When Susan’s eyelids began fluttering, Peg reached to take her daughter from Chris, but he forestalled her. “I’ll put her down for her nap,” he told Peg, doing just that. When he came back, Peg handed him a frosty glass of iced tea prepared the way he preferred it, with two lemon wedges, not just one.
They’d just settled back into their spots in the family room, Wally at Chris’s feet, when Peg put her own glass of iced tea down on a coaster on the end table and said, “So what’s wrong?” She didn’t give Chris a chance to answer before she continued, “I didn’t want to say anything in front of Susan—you would not believe how much she understands already. I told Joe he needed to watch his language now that Susan is so aware—and she mimics everything he says...especially the bad words.” Chris laughed, and Peg said, “But something’s up. You wouldn’t be here in the middle of the week, in the middle of the afternoon, if something wasn’t wrong.”
Chris shook his head and smiled wryly. “You must have second sight or something.” He hesitated, considering and then discarding his original idea of pumping Peg for info about Holly McCay on the sly. “The woman who was here a little while ago—”
“Holly?” Peg’s surprise was obvious.
“Yeah. Holly McCay. I’ve been hired by her in-laws to find her.”