She felt her eyes narrow at the wisdom of his words. Not that she was willing to turn a small boy over to a big man. “You’re right. The boy needs to be punished. Let me take care of it.” She’d spare the rod, but make Sammy realize the dangers of his choices. Perhaps she’d have him write lines. She sat up straighter, putting a fierce look on her face to convince him she meant to handle this well.
He dropped his foot to the floor and leaned forward, his gaze so demanding she couldn’t look away. “You think he should be whipped?” His voice was soft, so she couldn’t judge his meaning. He looked about, perhaps searching for a strap.
She rose to her feet, gripping the edge of the desk to hold herself steady, and gave him her most challenging look. “Mr. Marshall, I will not tolerate physical punishment in my classroom.”
He leaned back and crossed his ankle over his knee again, taking his time about answering, as if considering how to handle the noncompliant schoolteacher. “That’s good to hear.”
She’d misjudged him and she sat down again, relief leaving her weak.
He continued. “But that isn’t what I had in mind. And it’s Logan, if you don’t mind. Wouldn’t want to be confused with all those Marshalls older than me.”
“What do you have in mind then?”
“He stole from me. He can work for me to pay off his debt.”
She stared at the man. “He’s seven.”
“Old enough to run and fetch. Besides, what he does isn’t important, but owning up to what he did is.”
His suggestion was so totally unexpected that she didn’t know what to say. Every time Logan opened his mouth, he surprised her. She’d been expecting harshness. Instead, he’d shown compassion and caring. She slowed her breathing as she realized she’d expected a lack of sympathy and understanding such as she’d experienced from her parents.
He nodded, taking her silence to mean agreement. “Tomorrow after school then? Or do you think he should come over at noon? Yes.” He answered his own question. “Noon would be better. Wouldn’t want to keep him from his chores at home.”
She pursed her mouth. “I’d like to know why he comes to school without a lunch.”
“Like you said, he’s seven. I’m guessing he forgot it.”
“Four days in a row?” Was now the time to mention the other things she’d noticed?
Logan chuckled. “Little boys can forget lots of times.” He got to his feet.
He was about to leave, but she wasn’t through. She wasn’t believing that a hungry boy would forget his lunch four days in a row. She rose to better face him as she spoke. “I believe there’s more to it than that.” She’d seen bruises on his arms and in his eyes.
He studied her, a challenge and perhaps a warning in his sky-blue eyes. “Send the boy over at noon. If he forgets his lunch again he might like to share mine.” He strode from the room.
Drained, Sadie sank to her chair. Her head fell to her cradled arms on the desktop.
How had she been railroaded into agreeing to send Sammy across the street at noon hour? But at least he’d get fed. She’d pray he’d also repent of stealing. But something else bothered her. Logan seemed upset at her suggestion there was more than forgetfulness to Sammy not having a lunch. But she knew there was something not right about Sammy’s situation, and she would do her best to find out what it was. She wouldn’t let the Marshalls’ power stop her, but she would have to tread carefully—because if she angered them, she could lose her job.
The next day Sadie called Sammy to her desk on the pretext of going over his work.
“Sammy, I’d like to meet your parents. Can you ask them when would be a good time for me to call?”
Sammy jerked back from leaning his elbows beside her on the desk. “No point you coming to visit.”
She held his gaze steadily for several seconds, but his eyes revealed nothing. “Why is that?” she asked when it became clear the boy would offer no explanation on his own.
Sammy shuffled his feet and looked past her right shoulder. “My father—”
She couldn’t help but notice how he stumbled on the word.
“He don’t care for company.”
“I see.” Except she didn’t. What reason could a man have for not wanting visitors? “Perhaps your mother would welcome a visit when your father is away.”
Sammy ducked his head and scuffed the toe of his shoe along the floor. “I’ll ask.”
“I’ll write a note.” She took a piece of paper and penned a request to visit, folded it and handed it to Sammy. “Give that to your mother.”
Sammy stuffed the note into his pocket. “Can I go now?”
She thought of mentioning the plan for him to help Logan at noon but, not knowing how he would react, she decided to wait until it was too late for him to run off. “Yes, you may.” Sadie watched him return to his seat. Would he give his mother the note or would it be forgotten in his pocket?
All too soon noon hour arrived. She told the children to eat their lunches. Sammy again had not brought one. “Sammy, would you please come to my desk?”
The boy stuck out his chin in a defiant gesture and swaggered toward her.
She might have found his bravado amusing if it wasn’t so sad. Aware that the other children watched and listened intently, she nodded toward the door that opened into the store. “We’ll talk out there.”
She didn’t touch him, yet she felt his trembling. The poor child. “You have nothing to be afraid of.” Her words offered him no comfort. She would have put an arm around him and drawn him to her side, but every previous attempt at physical contact had caused him to shrink back and she must respect his wishes in the matter. In time, he would learn to trust her.
They stepped into the store. Thankfully, no one but George Marshall, the owner of the store, was in and, apart from sparing them a friendly nod, he was busy rearranging an assortment of tools. A rather noisy job that would enable her conversation to be private. She faced Sammy.
“Mr. Logan Marshall has offered to let you go over to the schoolhouse for the lunch break.”
Sammy’s eyes narrowed. “Why?”
The door to the street opened and Logan strode in. He called a greeting to his uncle as he crossed the floor.
Sadie told herself there was no cause for a case of jitters, and yet her heart fluttered madly and her blood pounded in her cheeks. Men always made her nervous, but this was a different reaction and it defied explanation...a fact she didn’t appreciate.
Sammy pressed his back to the door and his fists curled, making Sadie forget her own reaction. The poor child feared he was in trouble.
Logan tipped his head toward her in greeting, then turned to Sammy. “Well, young man, did your teacher tell you of our arrangement?”
“She said I had to go with you.” Defiance colored each word.
“I didn’t get time to explain why.” She would let Logan do it.
He flickered a look at her that carried a whole world of accusation.
She ignored it. Her reasons for not telling Sammy sooner were valid.
Logan gave Sammy his full attention. “You stole my lunch two times.”
Sammy’s only