“But they will find out who she is,” Dale insisted the next evening to Lee. “They’re bound to! Laundry marks, or some item like that. They’ll discover in time that she was once my personal secretary—and from there the thing will go on.”
“Let it.” Lee shrugged, apparently quite indifferent. “They can’t do a thing to you, sir, not as long as I’m willing to swear that you were with me all the time. Don’t worry so.”
Dale said nothing. He stared at the end of his cigar absently as he held it in his hand. He and Lee were in the lounge of their hotel, clearing up the final details before their return to London on the morrow.
“Y’know,” Dale said finally, “the police will be bound to find out that I booked a compartment on the Scots Express. They will assume it more than unusual that my ex-secretary should be on the same train.”
Lee gave his slow smile. “They can assume all they like, sir, but the law cannot operate on an assumption—only on incontestable facts and witnesses, Otherwise you’re protected by the provision of the ‘reasonable doubt’. Anyway, it’s not certain that she fell from the Scots Express. It’s not even certain that she fell from a train at all.”
“Her scratches and bruises where she hit the gravel chippings will be all the police will need in that direction.... The police are not a gang of halfwits, Lee; they’ll find out from the booking office or somewhere that Janice took the Scots Express. It may be months before they do find out—but they will.”
“If you’re determined to worry yourself to a shadow, sir, I’m afraid there isn’t much I can do.”
“I can’t help but worry. I almost feel as though I really murdered her.”
“But you didn’t, sir—so you say.”
Dale stared. “So I say! Good God, man, you believe me, don’t you?”
“Implicitly, sir. And the police, if they ever catch up, will have to do the same thing—which they will with me to back you up.” Lee reflected over something, then he said quietly, “We’d better fix up these business matters, hadn’t we, sir?”
“Yes, I suppose so....” Dale made a bothered movement. “Wish I could concentrate better.”
Somehow he succeeded in dissociating his mind from the real problem and gave all his attention to the matter on hand—but the moment he relaxed the old ghost returned. Throughout the night, as he tried to sleep, he kept seeing the body of Janice Elton disappearing through the train doorway into the night. He wished he had the detachment of Martin Lee—but then, when he came to think of it, Lee could afford to be detached. He had been out in the corridor when the girl had killed herself, therefore he had nothing particular to worry about.
Dale felt better when he got back to London and placed something like two hundred and fifty miles between himself and the scene of the tragedy. It gave him a sense of security, however false, and as day succeeded day he managed to so involve himself in business affairs that the fate of Janice Elton touched him, but little. He even felt proud that he had not betrayed his secret worry in any way. His wife had not the least suspicion that he was troubled about anything, and his children were all married and away from home so he didn’t have to bother to hide his feelings from them. The only person who knew anything was Martin Lee and he seemed as though he couldn’t care less and never referred to the matter—unless it was to draw Dale’s attention to some item of newspaper news, which he might have missed. Usually, he hadn’t; no man was more avid for a newspaper than Morgan Dale.
The disturbing fact was that the police were apparently making progress in their ‘body on the line’ problem. They had got as far as discovering that the girl, still unidentified, had been thrown from a train after being murdered. Her various abrasions, according to the forensic department, proved this. Also, pathology had shown that strychnine had been administered in a dose of 11.75 grains—and the last thing the police seemed to believe was the possibility of suicide. Nor was there any mention of the poison bottle being found in her clenched fingers....
Disquieting facts, which gave Morgan Dale a good deal to think about. The only thing he could cling to was the obvious one: that he had not committed murder or even touched the girl.
Then, a fortnight after the events on the Scots Express, things took a turn—and in a most unpleasant way as far as Morgan Dale was concerned. He was busy in his private office one morning when Lee entered, thin, smiling, with a curious glitter of satisfaction in his eyes.
“Yes?” Dale asked briefly, without looking up from the work at his desk. “Something you, want, Lee?”
“As a matter of fact there is.”
The way the words were spoken, and without the usual ‘sir’, made Dale look up slowly in surprise. He eyed Lee, standing as subservient as ever, at the other side of the desk.
“As a matter of fact I’ve bought a house,” Lee said. “I thought you might be interested.”
“Interested?” Dale repeated vaguely. “Why yes, of course I am. Where is it exactly?”
“It’s in a high class part of London. The wife thinks it’s beautiful, and so do I. It will save me a great deal of time in getting to the office.”
“Good! Congratulations, Lee. You must have saved pretty hard to enable you to do a thing like that.”
Lee smiled. “As a matter of fact it’s going to cost around five thousand pounds.”
“Really? That’s a lot of money, Lee. What happened? Did you come into a legacy, or something?”
“No; nothing like that. The house isn’t paid for yet, but it will have to be by noon tomorrow, or I won’t get it. And that would be a big disappointment.”
“Yes, of course it would. But where are you going to get that kind of money? Five thousand pounds doesn’t grow on trees. Frankly, what possessed you to embark on such a fantastic scheme when you knew you couldn’t afford it?”
“But I can, Mr. Dale—or, to be more exact, you can.”
Dale threw down his pen on the rack. The vagueness had left his face and the normal bulldog look had returned. He impaled Lee with cold grey eyes,
“I can? What the devil do you mean by that?”
“It has been said, rather truthfully I think, that the labourer is worthy of his hire.... I’m the labourer.”
“What the hell are you talking about?”
Lee pulled up a chair and sat down indolently, a thing he had never done before in his employer’s office.
“I’m talking about Janice Elton, who was thrown from the Scots Express. I’m your right-hand man, the only man who can swear you never left my side during the time she died, In a word, I’m your only hope between freedom and a hangman’s rope.”
“Stop talking like a melodramatic idiot!”
“Melodrama isn’t intended, Mr. Dale—only facts.” Lee grinned irritatingly. “Those facts have the unfortunate habit of staring one in the face—”
“Now look here, you needn’t start trying to intimidate me, Lee. I’m not the sort you can easily frighten. Even if the police get this far—which I doubt—you can’t nail me down for anything. The ‘reasonable doubt’, remember? You said so yourself.”
“I know, but if I am forced to be unpleasant—which I don’t want to be—the police may discover Janice’s handbag, the note inside it—minus the envelope now, unfortunately—and even the empty bottle of strychnine. You’ll have your hands full explaining those away, particularly the bottle with your prints all over it, and hers when she struggled to stop you.”
“When