The Real Trump Deal. Martin E. Latz

May 28, 1987:

      Dear Donald,

      I have received your letter of May 26. I was disappointed that you continue to believe that you can force the City’s hand to your advantage through intimidation. It will not work…. I also refuse to place hundreds of millions of dollars in future taxes at risk so that you can more easily build a 15-millionsquare-foot luxury condominium and retail development…. If NBC chooses your site and you make a profit, that’s fine and the American way, but it will not be on the backs of the New York City taxpayer…. I urge you to refrain from further attempts to influence the process through intimidation. It should already be clear to you that this tactic is counterproductive.²²⁷

      This wasn’t just a personal feud between Trump and Koch. The city officials’ attitude toward Trump was summed up by NBC’s representative, Michael Bailkin, a former city official who had worked with Trump on the Commodore deal.

      Bailkin indicated “the city did not like or trust Trump and was being forced to do business with him.”²²⁸

      But Donald Trump wasn’t prepared to give up on Television City even without NBC. How could he proceed? Threaten to support a new mayor in the 1989 elections.

      He met in Trump Tower with Lee Atwater, head of the Republican National Committee, and Roger Stone, the GOP consultant who was Donald’s lobbyist, and discussed ways he could put a fortune on the line against Koch without violating campaign finance limits. The strategy they came up with, leaked to the newspapers, was that he would spend up to $2 million on commercials that assailed Koch yet endorsed no one.²²⁹

      Later, after several political developments, and with Koch looking better in the polls, Trump dropped this effort.

      We know Trump’s advertising threat was empty. How? Trump and Koch ran into each other at Cardinal John O’Connor’s residence on Christmas eve 1988, shortly after Trump made this threat. According to Trump Show, “Donald [there] confided [to Koch] that he wasn’t really going to buy the commercials attacking Koch that he’d announced only days before.”²³⁰

      Koch lost that election. But before he left, he put another nail in the coffin for Trump’s Television City. It was yet another example of how Trump’s threats backfired. According to Trump Show,

      In the final months of the mayor’s twelve-year reign, top Koch officials moved to push the administration’s favorite projects to the top of the certification list…. [Trump’s Television City was placed] on the bottom. It was the first time that City Hall had ever dictated the priority list for certification.²³¹

      A footnote. NBC and New York City negotiated a deal directly in which New York City gave NBC and Rockefeller Center a “thirty-five-year property tax abatement, $800 million in partially tax exempt bond financing, and a fifteen-year sales tax write-off on most of an estimated billion in machinery and equipment purchases…. [This was] the richest package of public benefits ever given [to] a city business.”²³²

      Its value to NBC? $98 million.²³³

      Trump’s reaction? Threaten to sue. He also claimed the city deal gave NBC “substantially more tax abatements” than had ever been offered for Television City and that it created a “horrible precedent.” NBC’s representative Bailkin conceded this, noting that NBC received a better package than anything it had offered Trump.²³⁴

      This seems strange. Why would the city give up a financially better deal with Trump to go with NBC? Only one reason—the city distrusted Trump. This had value.

      One final comment on this deal, this one from Trump.

      There were some who told me that I was hurting my chances for zoning approval by taking on Koch in the media. They may well have been right. I’ve waited a long time to build on the West Side, and I can wait a little longer to get the zoning I feel is necessary. In the end, I will build Television City with or without NBC and with or without the current administration.²³⁵