Фрейд и Льюис. Дебаты о Боге. Арман Николи

of Sigmund Freud, vol. II, pp. 416–417.

      141

      Ibid., pp. 416–418.

      142

      Lewis, Miracles, p. 35.

      143

      Lewis, The Screwtape Letters, pp. 162–163.

      144

      Nicholi, The Harvard Guide to Psychiatry, p. 282; American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, p. 349.

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