Cassia pressed her hand over her mouth so he wouldn’t hear her gasp. She recognized that voice, even without a face to it: he was the man from Christie’s who’d stolen The Fortune Teller away from her.
But why was he here now at Penny House? How had he known where to find her? Or had he followed her here, intent on further humiliating her?
“What the lady is called is of no importance to you, sir,” Pratt ordered, his eyes hooded. “You would do far better to consider your own situation, and how it will be viewed by a judge. Forced entry, trespassing, threats of violence against the people of this house—such charges will not be taken lightly by a court of law.”
“But as they are all lies of your making, they shall not be considered at all.” The man paused, and Cassia knew he must be smiling. “Now what would those selfsame courts make of your treatment of me, I wonder? A respectable gentleman of wealth and position, treated like some sort of thieving scoundrel—but you can vouch for me, can’t you, Cassia? You can tell them what kind of man I am, can’t you?”
She flushed at the intimacy he implied, but before she could speak, Pratt answered for her.
“Do not reply, miss,” he said. “The rascal has no right to address you, let along to ask you to speak on his behalf.”
“Very well, then,” the man said. “Forgive me my rascally ways, my dear Cassia. I shall defend myself.”
Cassia took a step forward, stunned that he’d dare be so presumptuous. He’d no right to say such things, or to shame her this way before the others, and she longed to tell him exactly that. But she’d promised Amariah she’d behave, and as hard as it was to keep quiet, Cassia did, biting back the rebuttal the man deserved.
“Sir, you still do not seem to understand.” Amariah’s smile was tightly polite. “Penny House is a club for the first gentlemen of this country, where they can amuse themselves among their peers. Admission tonight is by invitation only, sir, and regardless of what my sister says of you, you were not invited.”
“But I should have been.” With his arms still restrained, he tossed his dark hair back from his forehead with an impatience that Cassia also recognized all too well. “You should all be on your knees to beg me to stay, instead of tossing me out in St. James Street like yesterday’s rubbish.”
That was more than enough for Pratt. “What is your name, sir?” he demanded. “Your home?”
“I am Richard Blackley, of Greenwood Hall in Hampshire,” the man answered, the pride in his voice unmistakable. “Recently returned from my plantations in the royal colony of Barbados, and presently residing at the Clarendon.”
“You lie, sir.” Pratt’s words were clipped with contempt. “The true owner of Greenwood Hall is not you, but Sir Henry Green. The estate has been in his family for centuries.”
“But no longer.” Again Cassia guessed the man—he had a name now, Mr. Richard Blackley—must be smiling, despite the edge that had crept into his voice. “Shortly before I sailed, Sir Henry and I engaged in an evening of cards in a tavern in Bridgetown. He was drunk, and he lost. I wasn’t, and I won, and now own Greenwood.”
Pratt’s expression didn’t change. “Is there anyone here who can vouch for what you claim, sir?”
Blackley shrugged, or would have, if the other two hadn’t held his arms. “I doubt it, not in this crowd. Best to ask poor Sir Henry himself. If you can find him, that is. Ruin can make a man damned near invisible.”
Cassia listened, shocked. Since coming to London, she’d heard many stories of men who’d played deep and had lost everything, but the stories had always been remote, as distant as a nursery tale. Rich gentlemen lost money they could spare, and Penny House’s bank would profit for the sake of the poor.
But this careless, offhanded description by one man who’d stripped another of his patrimony had such a grim ring of reality that Cassia couldn’t look at Mr. Blackley the same way. At the auction she had called him a pirate and a thief. How could she have known how true that was?
“Cassia.” Her sister’s inflection dragged Cassia back to the little room. “Is this the gentleman you met today at Christie’s?”
She nodded, and the two guards released him. He shook himself free, squaring his shoulders and shooting the cuffs of his black coat. He took another second to smooth back his hair, and then, ready at last, he turned around.
“Miss Cassia Penny,” he said, his bow more an athlete’s than a courtier’s. “How happy I am to make your formal acquaintance. But will you now say the same of me, I wonder? Can I trust you to speak the truth?”
Cassia lifted her chin, determined to meet his eye without flinching. He was even more handsome in his evening clothes than she remembered from this afternoon, and the advantage it gave him was decidedly unfair.
“You can trust me to be truthful, Mr. Blackley,” she said, her voice slow and deliberate, “because this is a square house in every way, you know.”
“So you do know him, Cassia?” Amariah asked. “This is the man?”
“The man who outbid me fairly for the painting?” Cassia forced herself to smile, opening her fan before her in a graceful arc. He was daring her to blush, daring her to look away or stammer, and she would not do it. She would treat him like every other gentleman here tonight, no better nor no worse. “Yes, Amariah, it was Mr. Blackley.”
He bowed again, though not as low, so he could keep watching her. “Your servant, Miss Penny,” he said softly. “But you knew that already, didn’t you?”
Swiftly she looked away, back to her sister. “But that is all, Amariah. Beyond Mr. Blackley’s paying a preposterous amount for a very average painting, I cannot speak for his family, his estate or his honor, and that is the truth.”
Cassia smiled at her sister, hoping she’d just damned Mr. Blackley with the faintest praise possible.
But she hadn’t, not at all.
“I cannot ask you for anything more than the truth, Cassia,” Amariah said. “And I thank you for it.”
While she thought, she patted her palms gently together, the sound muted by her gloves, and Cassia’s heart sank. From the way her sister’s brows had lowered, just short of a frown, Cassia knew she was calculating exactly how much of Mr. Blackley’s money could be pried from his pockets and into their charities. His family and his honor—or their lack—didn’t amount to a pile of garden dirt next to that. Amariah was going to let Mr. Blackley stay, and nothing that Cassia could say now was going to change her mind.
Pratt cleared his throat. “Forgive me, Miss Penny, but we should all be returning to the—”
“And so we shall, Mr. Pratt.” Amariah’s face was once again serene. “Mr. Blackley, you may stay. Dine with us, play at our tables, amuse yourself however you please. But please recall, sir, that Penny House is a respite for gentlemen, and not a Caribbean tavern made for brawling. Even a breath of trouble from you, sir, and you will be banned from here for the rest of your life.”
“Hah,” Blackley said. “There’s nothing like a threat to make for a damned cheerful welcome.”
“As my sister said, Mr. Blackley, you will find only the truth in this house.” Amariah glided past him to return to the others, Pratt and the guards behind her, and Cassia hurried to join them. “Now unless there is anything more you might wish from—”
“Your sister,” he said. “I want her.”
Cassia stopped abruptly. “Mr. Blackley, I am not—”
“As my guide, that is.” His smile was wicked, teasing, knowing she’d misinterpreted exactly as he’d planned. “Since I’m new here