Оценка готовности стран СНГ к созданию валютного союза с Россией. А. Ю. Кнобель

работе предпринимается попытка оценить готовность к созданию валютного союза следующими странами: Азербайджан, Армения, Беларусь, Грузия, Казахстан, Кыргызстан, Молдова, Россия, Таджикистан, Туркменистан, Узбекистан, Украина. Таким образом, в данном исследовании мы будем упоминать СНГ, подразумевая также и Грузию, несмотря на официальную приостановку членства этой страны с 18 августа 2009 г.

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