Over the century’s literature, mothers as rational, human-sized teachers decline in favor of diminutive fairies; concurrently, the split between science and religion allows for the emergence of a secular language of wonder and magic. At the beginning of the century, “scientific material seemed to be perfectly suited to the task of education and training the mind while inculcating a belief in God,” explains Alan Rauch, and children learned that “science and religion were harmonious” (1989, p. 14). But as evidence mounted supporting evolution and the Earth’s geological formation, science writing turned away from investigating nature for evidence of God and instead described feelings inspired by nature. “Facts as mere facts, are dry and barren,” advises Arabella Buckley, “but nature is full of life and love, and her calm unswerving rule is tending to some great though hidden purpose” (quoted in Rauch 1989, p. 17). Using rhetorical strategies once castigated as Deist (but now acceptably devout), Buckley refers obliquely to “nature’s God” and an “Unseen Power,” and encourages children’s spiritual feelings over dogma.
Other writers reconcile science and religion by the once unthinkable solution of relegating each to its own sphere. D.W. Godding assures readers in First Lessons in Geology (1847) that geology is “a witness to the truth of God,” yet quickly acknowledges, “The bible was given for our spiritual benefit, … but it was not intended for a book of science, and therefore does not treat at large upon scientific matters” (1847, p. 11). Godding’s near separation of science and religion, now commonplace, prepares the way for science writing that sets aside religion entirely while still expressing awe before sublime forces. But as Kathleen McDowell (McDowell and Nappo 2012) demonstrates, certain science topics such as evolution emerged as controversial hot spots even as religious reflections diminished, and publishers strove to satisfy two bifurcated audiences.
Geography, Travel, and History
What science writers like Hooker accomplish through developmental narratives, travel writers accomplish through spatial narratives. By organizing information by the child’s location, travel writing shows that everyday chance encounters present learning opportunities, a flexible approach reflected in their wide-ranging curricula. Travel writing teaches geography and foreign cultures or “manners,” but just as often extends to natural history, trade, regional products, popular tourist sites, and local history – sometimes all in the same volume, unified by the child explorer, after the fashion of a picaro novel.
Travel books for children lie on a spectrum between fiction and nonfiction (a matter of little importance to audiences of the time), with fictional family characters who narrate factual travel information. The fictional framework is the means for adapting eclectic source material from salty travel accounts for adults into books deemed appropriate for children. In her Preface to Juvenile Travellers (1801), Priscilla Wakefield frankly advertises her sources for European travels as “Brydone, Cox, Moore, Radcliffe, Southey, and Thickness.” While these authorities guarantee the quality of her work, such adult travel books are “unfit” for children, “many of them containing passages of an immoral tendency, or treating upon subjects above their comprehension” (p. iii–iv). Indeed, Wakefield, the highest paid of publisher Harvey Darton’s talents, built her reputation as a naturalist by her expert reformulation of Linnaean classification from sexual organs to nations, tribes, and families, which children might inspect with propriety (George 2007). Her geography books perform a similar service. The practice of compiling from multiple sources accounts for the heteroglossia (or patchwork of forms) in children’s travel writing. Wakefield’s books piece together commentary from her third-person narrator, letters from one sibling to another, excerpts from family journals, stories read from books, and accounts quoted from fellow travelers. Skillful authors gain authority through purposeful, judicious borrowing, which creates interlocutor moments when books show children how to write about their travels, collect anecdotes from other travelers, and engage in journaling.
The territory covered by travel writing and geography books ranges from regional day trips to circumnavigation of the globe. On a local scale, rural walks – a cross between travel literature and science writing – explore chance lessons offered by neighborhood rambles. Popularized with Sarah Trimmer’s An Easy Introduction to the Knowledge of Nature and Reading the Holy Scriptures (1780), the rural walk features an adult instructor who converses with young siblings about the natural world, providing a mix of scientific detail and moral lessons. Successors to Trimmer include Charlotte Smith’s Rural Walks (1795), Rambles Further (1796), and Minor Morals (1798) and Jane Webb Loudon’s Glimpses of Nature (1844) and the Young Naturalist’s Journey (1840). Many of these stories borrow from John Aiken’s “Eyes, and No Eyes; or, the Art of Seeing” (1793), in which two boys report opposite experiences of a country walk: the first boy gets bored and walks straight home, while the second collects curious specimens on a meandering ramble, and presents his findings to his father with questions (Ruwe 2014, pp. 108–120). Other books adopt a strain from William Paley’s Natural Theology (1802), which begins with the discovery of a pocket watch on a country walk. Paley’s argument (that nature provides attentive observers with evidence for divine creation) was adapted into a rural walk narrative for children in Maria Hack’s Harry Beaufoy, or, the Pupil of Nature (1821) and Priscilla Wakefield’s Instinct Displayed (1811).5
If traveling about the neighborhood tends to teach natural history, touring Britain favors national character, regional history, and commerce. The four siblings in Priscilla Wakefield’s A Family Tour Through the British Empire (1804) describe precisely how they travel through each town from England through the Lake Country, where the boys head for Scotland and Ireland, while the girls tour Wales before they rejoin and head home. The separation allows the children to model journaling and letter-writing. Each cathedral or country estate is layered with past events, patrons, imprisoned usurpers, and famous artists. The children tour ancient caves and mines and investigate modern wonders, such as the Duke of Bridgewater’s navigable canal that supplied Manchester with coal. Compared with modern travel, museums and inns are noticeably sparse; the family relies on a network of friends and wealthy families, and they hire local guides to help them access remote places. Wakefield’s book could serve as a field guide for families, complete with practical hints on which mountain hikes are toddler-friendly and which beaches have the best seashells. The book even provides an itinerary and map with the journey marked.
With the growth of manufacturing, touring trade and industry constitutes its own subgenre, which prefigures social problem novels by Elizabeth Gaskell and Charles Dickens. Stories of families who tour Britain – such as Maria Edgeworth’s Harry and Lucy (1801–1821), Mrs. Brook’s A Dialogue between a Lady and Her Pupils (ca. 1800), and Isaac Taylor’s Scenes of British Wealth (1823)