“He’s waiting for you.” He opened the door to the sheriff’s office, and she sashayed inside. “By the way, he hasn’t questioned Serena yet. She was too upset when he arrested her.”
Her eyebrow quirked at that, but she flipped a strand of her long black hair over her shoulder and forged on. The moment she entered the office, the sheriff’s eyes lit up.
“Kay Krantz,” she said, then extended her hand.
Sheriff Gray stood and shook her hand. “You’re representing Serena Stover?”
“That’s right.” Her fingers tightened around the strap of her shoulder bag. “I’d like to see a copy of the arrest warrant.”
Frowning, the sheriff snagged it from his desk and pushed it into her hands. “I can assure you it’s in order.”
She studied it for a moment, then dropped it on to the desk. “Okay, let me see my client now.”
“Fine,” Sheriff Gray said. “I’ll move her to the interrogation room and we’ll all convene there.” He glanced at Colt. “You can wait here.”
“He’s with me,” Kay said, then smiled when Gray narrowed his eyes. “My assistant.”
“Yeah, right,” Gray muttered, then jangled his keys as he went to retrieve Serena.
Five minutes later, they were all seated in the interrogation room. Serena and Kay sat on one side of the table across from the sheriff. Colt parked himself at the end. Gray had already given him orders to keep his mouth shut.
He hoped he could comply, but he wasn’t promising anything.
Still, he adopted his poker face, the one he used when he was undercover. Sometimes a person’s mannerisms said more than their words. He just hoped that Serena told the truth.
And that she didn’t have any ghosts in her past the sheriff could use against her.
SERENA GRIPPED her clammy hands together, bracing herself to be ripped apart by the sheriff’s questions.
Kay Krantz squeezed her hand, and she took a deep breath. When the lawyer had introduced herself, Serena remembered the attorney’s name from a big case in Raleigh.
Kay Krantz had won.
Hopefully, she was as talented as the article had claimed.
“All right, Sheriff,” Kay said. “Show us what you have.”
Sheriff Gray’s face remained solemn as he opened a folder and spread photos of a ransacked bedroom in front of them. The light was dim, the furniture old and outdated, but it was the mess that caught Serena’s eyes. Clothes were scattered in disarray, a lamp was overturned, a wineglass broken on the faded carpet.
Then her gaze fell to the bed, and her stomach pitched. The white bed linens were tangled and drenched in blood.
“We believe Mr. Rice was killed here in his bedroom.” Sheriff Gray gestured toward the crimson stains on the sheets and floor. “As you see from the amount of blood loss, he was apparently stabbed several times and bled out.”
Serena couldn’t take her eyes off the blood. No one could have survived that much blood loss.
Kay gestured toward the other photos of the crime scene. “Then where is Rice’s body?”
The sheriff twisted toward Serena, his suspicious look sending a chill up her spine. “We were hoping Ms. Stover could tell us that.”
“I have no idea,” Serena blurted. “I—”
“Shh, don’t say anything right now.” Kay placed her hand over Serena’s to calm her.
“What about the murder weapon?” Kay asked.
The sheriff pointed to a serrated kitchen knife on the floor beside the tangled bedding, and cold fear clawed at Serena. Dear God…that knife looked exactly like one from the set Parker’s parents had given them as a wedding gift.
“Blood matches Rice’s. And we found Ms. Stover’s prints on the knife, and the wineglass.”
Serena gasped. “But I’ve never been to the man’s house.”
Sheriff Gray leaned forward, hands gripping the file edge. He slid another photograph from the bottom of the stack and cocked one brow.
“Then how did your underwear and prints get in his bedroom, Ms. Stover?”
Serena stared at a pair of her black lace underwear in shock. “I have no idea, I told you I’ve never been in his house…”
The sheriff’s look hardened. “Just like you weren’t guilty of assault when you were a teenager?”
Serena gasped. “I wasn’t. Besides, those records were supposed to be sealed.”
Again Kay covered her hand to silence her. “Serena, please. Let me handle this.”
Serena gave Colt an imploring look, hoping for support, but his face was a granite mask revealing nothing.
They had to believe her. She hadn’t been at Lyle’s house.
Of course, she hadn’t attacked that guy when she was fifteen either. She had been defending herself. But the boy who’d accosted her came from a rich family who’d paid a high-priced attorney to drag her through the mud, and she’d ended up in the juvenile detention center.
So how had her underwear and knife and her fingerprints gotten in Lyle’s place?
Sheriff Gray laid another photograph in front of them. “These are from Rice’s computer.” He spread several printouts of emails in front of her, then used a pencil to point to them. “Please read these emails, Ms. Stover.”
Trembling inside, Serena leaned forward to study the screen and Kay did the same.
I love you, Lyle. I won’t let you leave me. I’ll kill you before I let you go.
You’re mine forever.
Serena
Nausea settled over her as she scanned a dozen more. Each note poured out her love, begged the man to not leave her, the latter ones becoming increasingly threatening.
But she hadn’t sent them.
“Judging by these emails, it appears you were obsessed with Lyle Rice.” The sheriff’s chair squeaked as he leaned back, studying her. “Rice wasn’t upset because you rejected him, Ms. Stover. It was the other way around. You were stalking him.”
“No…that’s not true—”
“Be quiet, Serena.” Kay’s fingers tightened over Serena’s. “Sheriff, how do you know those emails came from my client? Did you have a warrant to search her computer?”
Sheriff Gray smiled. “I’m not some dumb local like you think, Ms. Krantz.” He lifted a manila envelope from a file box and dropped it on the desk, then removed Serena’s cell phone, which was sealed in a plastic bag.
“When we booked Ms. Stover, we collected her personal items. The emails came from this phone.”
Serena’s heart pounded. “That’s impossible.”
“Someone else could have used that phone to plant those emails,” Kay pointed out calmly.
Sheriff Gray shrugged, then angled his head toward Serena. “But you sent them, didn’t you, Ms. Stover? You were desperate for attention after your husband’s death, so you fell for the first man who came along. Then you couldn’t stand it when Rice broke it off with you, so you stalked him, then went to his house and stabbed him.” Sheriff Gray’s voice hardened. “Now tell us where you dumped the body, and maybe we can talk a plea.”
“There’s no