The elephant in the room was that Noah had always chosen women who had an uncanny resemblance to Monica, and who were just as wealthy.
It confounded him that he would choose women like her. “That’s all been nothing more than coincidence.”
“Really? Deirdre? New Orleans? A dead ringer for Monica.”
Noah was angry instantly. He’d put a lot of energy into forgetting Deirdre and her betrayal. He didn’t need Audrey bringing it up now.
“Don’t go there, Audrey.”
“Deirdre might have looked like Monica, but Monica is nothing like that woman.”
“Okay, so I showed poor judgment. I won’t again. Okay?”
Unfazed by his anger, Audrey urged, “Everybody underestimates Monica. Just don’t let your bias have you judging her wrongly.”
Both Audrey and Noah had been on the receiving end of the false assumptions that people made based on flimsy evidence—Audrey because of the way she chose to dress in retro forties and fifties clothing, and Noah because of the same thing—the way he chose to dress—and also because of the green, organic lifestyle he lived. He would probably fit in better in a big city than in rural Colorado.
But in Colorado, he got to grow things, to plant seeds and produce something out of nothing that could feed those in need...and it was the best feeling on earth.
In high school, he and Audrey had bonded as the misfits who didn’t dress like others. They’d been best buds ever since.
“Noah, you weren’t too hard on her, were you?”
With one hand, he wrestled his empty Mason jar into his cooler bag, avoiding her gaze. “I wasn’t patient with her,” he admitted, but, compelled to defend himself continued, “For Pete’s sake, Audrey, every time I look at her I still get tongue-tied. When she showed up at the farm this morning, I actually stuttered!”
Her eyebrows shot up. “That bad? Still?”
“Yeah. It’s still that bad. When’s the last time you heard me stutter? It’s like I’m thirteen years old again! And for what? For a spoiled, ditzy blonde.” So, yeah, he’d been harsh, but that was a whole lot better than stuttering.
“Noah, don’t call her names. You forget that Monica is family,” Audrey admonished.
Chastened, he calmed himself and said, “I do. I often forget. I’m sorry. It’s just that I’ve never understood how you two could be so different and yet get along so well.”
“First, it’s because she’s not quite who you think she is, and second, because we both lost our mothers when we were so young. Mine when I was five, but poor Monica in childbirth. She never even knew hers.”
“And this helped how?”
When Audrey hesitated to share, Noah bumped her shoulder with his. “I’m just trying to understand this space alien who’s tearing up my radishes.”
Audrey huffed out a laugh and then grew serious. “Okay. Here goes. Losing a parent so early leaves a hollow spot in your life along with a low-grade sadness. It doesn’t matter how deeply you bury the sadness, it’s still there. Often, you feel like you don’t have anyone to talk to about it, even your other parent. My dad was grieving, too, but didn’t know how to express it.”
“What about Billy?”
“I think he dealt with it by ignoring it, by surrounding himself with friends. By becoming the class clown and making sure that everyone, including himself, was always laughing. Plus, when it happened, he was older and less dependent on Mom than I was.”
“That makes sense.” Noah picked at his egg sandwich. “Monica felt that way, too?”
“Yes. She also understood that it makes you different from your classmates and friends who still have both parents. Mother’s Day is particularly hard.”
Finished with her salad, Audrey passed him her empty jar. “Knowing that someone else in the world understood how I felt gave me a measure of comfort, even though I was already a teenager by then.”
“Okay,” Noah conceded. “She might have more depth than I’ve given her credit for, but she pulled up eight of my baby radishes before I caught her. It frustrates me, Audrey. That’s food that won’t make it onto some hungry person’s plate.”
Audrey sobered. He knew she admired his passion for feeding the needy. Of all of the people in his life, she truly understood him.
“She said she thought they were weeds,” he continued. “They were the only plants in a row I’d already weeded.”
“Sounds like a problem with communication.”
“Yeah, there was definitely a problem. I communicated. She didn’t listen.”
He stared at Audrey, begging her to understand how screwed he was.
“What am I going to do about her, Audrey? I’m thirty-seven years old, a sane and reasonable grown man, but I’ll be seeing her nearly every day this summer and I might as well be back in high school.” He added miserably, “Déjà vu all over again.”
* * *
AT LUNCHTIME, MONICA headed to the bar at the end of Main Street, knowing her father had his midday meal there every day. She wanted to question him about his relationship with the judge.
She’d tried to contact him last night, but he’d been out and hadn’t been answering his cell, leaving her with the strange suspicion he was avoiding her.
In the courtroom yesterday, she’d been upset by the judge’s lack of professionalism. His sly looks, the pleasure he seemed to take in convicting her, had irked her and yet, he had agreed to the plea bargain that got her sentence reduced. So confusing. She meant to get to the bottom of it.
The scents of fried food made her mouth water, but Monica was watching her figure.
When she slid into the booth across from her dad, he didn’t seem surprised to see her.
She ordered a cup of coffee with skim milk and a toasted bagel with light cream cheese. Her father picked up his glass of Scotch to drain its contents, looking everywhere but at her. Curious.
“What was that all about?” Monica asked.
“What?” He stared at a point behind her left shoulder.
“You know what, Daddy. I heard the noise you made when Judge Easton entered the courtroom and sat on the bench. When he passed down my sentence, he actually smirked.”
Milton Ian Accord rattled the ice cubes in his glass. He hated his first name. Everyone in town knew him as Ian. Why on earth the Accord family used such old-fashioned names was beyond Monica. Monica. Case in point. An old-fashioned name.
They used names of ancestors that had been handed down from generation to generation. She supposed it was simply tradition.
Ian carried his age well, but signs of unhappiness, of discontentment, hovered around a sullen mouth. Whatever was bothering him had come on lately, but he wouldn’t share it with her.
She stared at him hard. She wasn’t going away. He finally gave in. “Gord Easton and I went to high school together.”
“High school?” That old man and her dad?
He nodded.
“Same grade?”
Another nod.
“That’s hard to believe. He looks a lot older than you.”
“Gord likes sun, whiskey and cigars, and has the money to indulge as much as he wants.” Tone derisive,