We as geeks and nerds have gone from the outcast to the cool individuals who know all the fun facts you’ll never get in a movie. Now our goal is to educate you about what has happened with each of these movies, and then to present the opinions and reviews of these movies from a nostalgic old comic book reader and a comic book reader that jumped on board in the recent years with the new material. You will also notice entire segments for Superman and Batman while Marvel is lumped together.
[no image in epub file]
12
This is not due to some fanboyism or preference for DC over Marvel. It’s actually based on the fact Superman and Batman have completely separate franchises, while Marvel is touted as a complete franchise to itself. Superman and Batman were handled separate from each other, but both learned from Marvel’s successes and that is proven by the last film in each of their franchises. As this is such a very opinion-based book, I thought it would be fun to bring in the members of Comicstorian team and explain who each of us is.
I am Benny, and I run the YouTube channel Comicstorian. On a frequent basis, we take comic book plots lines, cut them up into a ten-minute video, and read back what happened in a dramatic manner. The goal is to give people a general idea of a story that involves their favorite superheroes and entice them to go pick up a similar book or the book we read itself to get the full story.
I have held discussions about superhero theory, lore and plotlines. I have been reading comics since I was a child, when my father got me my first Superman comic. It was something that I could connect with my father about because we didn’t have very much else in common. Once he had introduced me to the world of comics, I would ride my bicycle miles down the road to the local store and fully immerse myself in this world. I did fall off the wagon around the time Spider-Man decided to have more clones than adventures, but the superhero movies X-Men and Spider-Man brought me back into the loving embrace of a new comic book. I started the channel Comicstorian in order to share my passion and love for all things comics with likeminded individuals. I never expected to meet and experience even half of what I have, which has led to the creation of this book.
[no image in epub file]
13
JASON
To say that writing movie reviews about comic book films is my destiny is not something that I would tout as one of my greatest accomplishments but it is certainly very cool. As a child I was always surrounded by great movies. My family is a family of cinephiles so I simply played along. As I grew older I learned that it wasn’t considered normal to obsess over films, which I thought was odd because people really seem to like movies. All of the pop culture I was exposed to centered on films with branding involving clothes, toys, and video games. Comic book and movie themed birthday parties were common place.
So what’s the big deal?
Why is it wrong to discuss ideas about who should be cast as Jean Gray, or who the next Batman villain should be? These are life altering important decisions! In college at Colorado State University I started writing movie reviews on a now defunct website called The Keen and Hair Reviews which was my attempt to be the Roger Ebert of the Twenty-First century.
Writing film reviews is unrewarding and serves no real purpose but to be therapeutic. It’s also a great way to create rote responses to people who continually ask me my opinions on a new film’s. Why are people asking me about my opinion all of the time? It’s because I became a full time manager at Grand Slam Sports Cards and Comics in 2008 after my career in teaching social studies was sidelined for numerous reasons. As a person who sits behind the comic counter I immediately become the pop culture expert. In fact it almost becomes my responsibility to see these comic book films first thing when they are released. I would like to say that the majority of the
[no image in epub file]
14
films I’ve reviewed in this work were at a midnight screening premiere, but I’d be lying.
When Benny the Comicstorian walked into my life in early 2014 it was quite interesting. He told me about his YouTubing shenanigans and I was blown away that I met one of these people who claims to make a living off of You-Tube. Shortly after he began to craft his identity of Comicstorian and I was asked to come along on the ride.
I created my YouTube identity of Indie-bookasaurus and started helping with videos by being in them or even scripting them. I actually have T-Shirts (shameless plug)! During this time I have started a movie review podcast titled End of the World Movie Reviews with my friend Andrew Saiger. It is still going and you can check it out if you want the more off color versions of some of these film reviews. All of this somehow leads to me writing movie reviews in this book, which is for a super nerd a great honor.
While I don’t hold a degree in being judgmental of cinema I hope you can appreciate the perspective of someone who is a professional at selling comic books and in many ways a professional comic movie reviewer. For some reason my reviews hold weight with some of my customers so I hope they hold some weight with you my dear reader!
DAN
My name is Dan Rumbles, and I’m the lead editor for the Comicstorian YouTube channel. Sure, I’ve read a couple of comics here and there throughout the years but it was in
[no image in epub file]
15
2015, when I became editor for Comicstorian, I really started to read them and gain a lot more appreciation for comics, characters, origins, and more. Some of my favorites include the X-Men, The Guardians of the Galaxy, and The Teen Titans.
The X-Men movies were some of my favorite growing up and definitely made me more open to the world of superheroes and comic books. Going back to those X-Men movies now, though, I realize how incorrect some of the information was and how some of the movies seemed even better when I didn’t know all the details about the mutants.
That being said, many of the movies we’ve decided to review in this book came out before I became so enveloped in the superhero genre. Because of this, a lot of my movie tastes and opinions have been, maybe understandably, influenced by more recent movies, plots, and special effects, which have evolved drastically over the years. I did my best to watch each movie as though I was watching it around the time it came out and judge its set, action, and special effects accordingly.
While I may be fairly new when it comes to comics and the history of the characters, maybe like some of you, I’d encourage readers to get stuck in, read and watch as much as you can, and you’ll soon start learning about what you like.
For this book, I’ve enjoyed watching the live-action interpretations of comics and worked to deliver some thoughtful opinions on some fantastic superhero franchises that have existed over the years.
[no image in epub file]
16
BENNY
Before we get started, I want to make it clear that I love some of these movies and hate others. I am very biased when it comes to comic book characters, especially DC. Because of this, I wanted to get the opinions of these two brilliant individuals: regular people like you and me who read a lot of comics and watched a lot of movies. So each section of the book will include our