The big issues of the day, such as racism, sexism, classism, ecology, and war, began to push me toward registering as a Democrat. I found Democrats, as a whole, more compassionate and tolerant. I learned that those who needed help were far beyond a stereotype of “takers” and “dependants.” The help was usually not a hand out but a hand up. At the same time, I became clearer about my own identity as a Christian, affirming the guidance of the Holy Spirit, the involvement in our world of Jesus Christ, and the necessity for me to develop a more social and global consciousness.
It is said that the conservative mind and the liberal mind are quite different. Perhaps they are. Some say that the staunch Republican and the staunch Democrat are almost like two different species because they have different values and visions of the future, and different ways of interpreting the Bible and message of Jesus. For many years, this difference has evolved into an opinion that a Christian could not possibly be anything except a Republican. Republican policies and Republican speeches that mention religion imply (and sometimes state absolutely) that the Republican Party carries the message of Jesus, and that the poor Democrats have lost the point and have obviously gone very far astray.1
We form our spiritual opinions about politics in different ways. Most Christians look at what Scripture says about issues. What does the Scripture say about the poor? Abortion? The environment? Helping the mentally and physically ill? Homosexuality? Education? Social programs for the poor and disadvantaged?
To what extent might Biblical translations, the meanings of words, and the context of the time change our viewpoint?
Some Christians, particularly Catholics, look to Church tradition and practice. How did the church fathers and mothers, saints, and historical practices address various issues? Did those interpretations change or remain the same through the ages? What are the influences that change our minds? How are new understandings guided by the Holy Spirit?
This book is written as a kind of Christian Political Apologetic. It is meant to clarify what we, as Christian Democrats, believe and why we believe it. Originally, it was an assignment from Adams Media Publishers, who wanted a book which would respond to the oft-repeated idea that the Christian vote was the Republican vote. Since I was a Christian Democrat with a theology background and experience as an author, they asked if I’d be willing to write a book articulating how we use our Christian values to inform our political decisions.
In this Third Edition, I have updated some of the political information, although the focus of Democrats and Republicans has been fairly consistent since I started researching this topic in 2005. However, this year shows some of the sharpest divisions of the values and actions between Republicans and Democrats.
I felt it was essential to do a 2016 edition because it is an important and groundbreaking election. Hillary Clinton may be the first woman president, and she may be one of the best-qualified candidates who have ever run for office. She brings her experience and knowledge base as a lawyer for the poor and disenfranchised, a governor’s wife who knows the workings of a state, a president’s wife who discussed issues and advised her husband, and as someone who researched and created health care policy, a senator, a secretary of state, and a presidential candidate twice. She knows the world—the international leaders and the way Congress works. She has proven she knows how to cross party lines and how to be strong and firm. She has influence and understands the potential of diplomacy. She is the only candidate who would be ready on Day One.
Bernie Sanders has long worked for a more equal economic system, for equality in our justice system, for a raise in the minimum wage, and for peace policies. He was one of the few who voted against George W. Bush’s Iraq War, which was considered by many to be one of the wiser votes in Congress.
Their views and policies are clear.
In the 2014 edition, I changed the subtitle. Originally, the subtitle was Why the Republicans Don’t Have the Corner on Christ, which was the publisher’s choice. Although I didn’t like the divisiveness implied in this subtitle, I recognized it was a direct response to the prevailing presumptions of 2006. In the last two editions, with the new subtitle, I have tried to remove some of the divisiveness of the first edition.
This book is written for Democrats who identify as Christians, to help them better understand how their spirituality leads them to political choices. I expect that some people who are spiritual but not necessarily Christian might also find this book helpful. The previous editions were read by many Independents and some Republicans who said they liked the book, and I hope some Independents and Republicans will read this edition as well. Perhaps, for them, it will open up a better understanding of why their brothers and sisters in Christ vote differently than they do. Perhaps it might break down some of the barriers and divisiveness that exist between parties and people. It may lead to all of us working together for a more loving nation. And for some, it may change their vote.
If you are unsure about which party and which policies best express your values, perhaps this book will bring you to some new decisions about who you are, what you believe as a citizen of our country and of our world, and what actions you can take to help create a society that is an expression of God’s grace, the love of Christ, and the manifestation of the Holy Spirit.
Chapter One
How Would Jesus Vote?
“[You] have neglected the weightier matters of the Law—justice, mercy, good faith!”
Matthew 23:23
Jesus and the prophets shared a vision for a people and a nation—that a nation would respond to its people with justice and mercy and good faith. These Christian values are also democratic values, asking us to come together to create a free, equal, and kind society that cares for all its citizens. We are asked to help remove structures that oppress its citizens. Christian values recognize the redemptive potential and possibilities of humanity. So does democracy. A democratic nation provides a voice for the majority as well as the minority, and promises freedom and protection for all. A democratic nation, founded on religious principles, struggles to create unity out of diversity, without compromising either one.
Which Is the Christian Political Party?
Both the Republican and Democratic parties, and some of the others as well, are made up of millions of Christians. But categorizing Christians is not so easy, since Christians fall into a number of different groups.
Fundamentalist Christians believe that every word in the Bible is the literal Word of God. Evangelical Christians believe that we must be Born Again by accepting Jesus Christ as our personal Savior, and that their work on earth is to spread the Gospel of Christ to all nations. Mainstream Protestants and Catholics, and many liberal and progressive Christians, believe that the true Word of God is not the Bible but Christ Jesus, who continues to reveal Himself and transform us. They see the Bible as inspired, but they are not literalists. They believe God’s work continues to develop and unfold in our modern world.
Christian Mystics put the focus on the Holy Spirit dwelling within. Some Mystics have visions and ecstatic experiences of the Living Christ. Some of these, such as the Quakers (including me), combine their Mystical devotions with social actions, believing that the work of the Spirit within leads us naturally to manifesting the work of the Spirit in the world.
Some Christians put their focus on the life and sayings of Jesus, and see him as a good man who is our model for a good life, but don’t see him as the Son of God. Nevertheless, they identify as Christian.
Some of these Christians, such as Catholics and mainstream Protestants and liberal Christians, are more apt to vote Democrat. Others, such as Fundamentalists and Evangelicals, are more apt to vote Republican. But the actual voting statistics are not quite so neat.
About one out of five Christian Evangelicals votes Democrat. The foremost evangelist of our time—Billy Graham—is a Democrat. In 2004, Catholics, and other Protestants, on the whole, were almost equally divided between