Van Horne was indeed furious. Nevertheless, there was nothing he could do except watch President Hayes arrive at Kansas City and leave for Fremont on the rival railway’s train. Stung to the quick and mortified beyond belief, he returned to the Chicago and Alton’s train. But he did not lose his cool in front of his friend. In a remarkable demonstration of self-control, he merely mentioned the rival railway’s coup as they as made their lonely way back from Kansas City to Chicago. But then he spotted his chance to get his own back. Crowds of people had assembled at small western stations to cheer the president on his way. So he persuaded Hopkins, who had worn a formal frock coat for this splendid occasion, to pretend that he was President Hayes and to wave to the eager onlookers — We must not disappoint the loyal citizens, Van Horne argued. As the handsome, suitably attired Hopkins stood on the train’s rear platform and graciously greeted the waiting throngs of people, they were just as impressed by him as they would have been by the president himself. Between these appearances, Van Horne and his friend enjoyed the abundance of fine food at their disposal. They sat down to a sumptuous dinner, with twenty-five waiters in attendance and a chef and five assistants to supply their every whim!
The climax came when the Chicago and Alton special train met up with its rival at an Illinois junction. There, Van Horne encountered General William Tecumseh Sherman, the commanding general of the U.S. Army. Sherman, who was travelling with the president’s entourage, entered Van Horne’s car to beg for a Scotch and soda, complaining that he had been travelling with the teetotalling president for four days without so much as one drink. Once satisfied, he invited Van Horne to go with him to meet Hayes, but the still aggrieved Van Horne declined. Finally, Sherman made his way back to his train, only to return with the president, who said how much he regretted the mix-up. News of the incident circulated widely in railroading circles, where rival railroaders crowed over the humbling of the hitherto invincible Van Horne. Before long, however, Van Horne regarded it all as a great joke — and dined out on the story countless times.
Although his new position at the Chicago and Alton was demanding, Van Horne still found time to add more specimens to his fossil collection. His passion for fossils had become widely known, and all along the railway lines the men kept an eye out for finds that might interest him. He also devoted leisure hours to another favourite pursuit — gardening. He had taken up this hobby at La Crosse, determined to produce larger and more luxurious flowers than his neighbours. In his quest for the perfect bloom, Van Horne dug his own beds, studied fertilizers, carefully tended each and every plant himself, and walked long distances on the Bluffs to obtain leaf mould for his roses. In Chicago he cultivated tulips and hyacinths in the attic and cellars of the family’s large brick home at 48 Park Avenue.
This spacious, rambling house may have been to Van Horne’s liking, but it did not please Addie. She was dismayed by the profusion of halls and predicted that their new home would be difficult to keep clean. “I wish I were back in our house [in La Crosse] a thousand times,” she wrote plaintively to her sister-in-law Mary in October 1878. This second Chicago interlude would be a trying one for Addie in other ways as well. She was still mourning her son Willie and enduring the long bout of ill health that followed his death. Chicago’s changeable climate, with its abundance of cool, windy weather, was another irritant, as were her husband’s many absences from home.
Most of Van Horne’s time away from Chicago was taken up with visits to La Crosse, where, in his continuing role as president of the Southern Minnesota, he oversaw the completion of the railway’s extension. He also had private business to conduct because he had invested in a few properties there, including a farm. Although he was still in his thirties, he was already taking the first steps towards becoming a financier.
Van Horne had been managing the Chicago and Alton for only one year when he accepted an offer to be general superintendent of still another railway — the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railroad, a rapidly expanding company with extensive mileage in Wisconsin, Illinois, Iowa, the Dakotas, Minnesota, and Missouri. His remarkable success in resurrecting the Southern Minnesota and the tenacity and resourcefulness with which he had waged the Chicago and Alton’s ferocious battles for traffic had caught the attention of the Milwaukee management. Van Horne’s particular type of genius, they were convinced, was just what was needed to consolidate the numerous railways that the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul was acquiring and to blend them into a harmonious, effective system. Accordingly, the railway offered him the title of general superintendent, but intended to give him all the duties and powers of a general manager. His new appointment was to begin on January 1, 1880.
Van Horne accepted the plum appointment because of the big salary he was offered — it was “a question of dollars and future,” he explained. He still felt a sense of loyalty to the Southern Minnesota Railroad and would have turned down the offer had he believed the company was in danger. But he knew that it was now under capable management and in respectable shape. And as the Chicago and Alton Railroad was flourishing, he had no qualms about leaving it.
New Year’s Day dawned with the family still in Chicago and Van Horne in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. He had not visited the city before — a beer-brewing capital noted for its bustling port, extensive gardens, and broad streets. He had been warned to expect a frigid reception from the men at the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul, but he wrote with relief to Addie, “I have been very cordially received here — more cordially than I could have expected in view of the harsh colours in which I have been pictured to the employees. From what I have heard some of them looked for a regular ogre with fangs and fiery breath.” Still, it was not all smooth sailing. Although his job qualifications were excellent, several important officials objected strenuously to a new man being placed over them and did not hesitate to express their antagonism. They even encouraged insubordination on the part of younger men. By 1881, though, Van Horne’s expertise, inexhaustible patience, natural buoyancy of spirit, and irresistible personality had won over all the disaffected.
During his first year with the Milwaukee railway, it acquired still more small lines. The task of integrating the railway’s different branches, such as the Chicago and Pacific, and welding them into one well-coordinated system presented a major challenge. But the most daunting task of all was to reduce the company’s operating costs. Here Van Horne started a revolution in the operation of railways, according to an unidentified railroader, and he implemented methods that are still in use today. He taught the railway world how to load freight cars to their fullest capacity and made eight hundred cars do the work previously done by a thousand. He applied similar strictures to engines and all the other equipment. His colleague, Frank Underwood, a future president of the Erie Railroad, reported: “Most of the present, up-to-date methods of transportation were thought out by him. Some of them have been enlarged and improved. The original suggestions, however, were his.”
As part of his campaign to streamline operations and reduce costs, Van Horne instituted a comprehensive store and accounting system. First, though, he appointed a three-member committee to study and report on the systems used by other large railways. One of the committee’s members was a young clerk, Thomas George Shaughnessy, who would soon play a leading role beside Van Horne in the construction of the Canadian Pacific Railway.
Among Van Horne’s many responsibilities was the erection of new stations and buildings. He welcomed this challenge because it involved him in architecture and art — two of his personal passions. Previously, railways had been content to erect cost-saving, efficient buildings. Van Horne, however, aimed to design structures that not only met the requirements of function and economy but also harmonized with their surroundings and appealed to the eye. A typical Van Horne station was a rather Spartan, two-storey building that provided living quarters for the stationmaster and his family on the second floor. Adjoining this utilitarian structure was a one-storey wing where freight could be stored. When the Canadian Pacific Railway was built, many of the depots erected in western Canada would incorporate this basic design.
During his stint at the Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railroad, the company tried to get possession of