June’s fifth and sixth crime novels, Faculty of Murder (1961) and Make-Up for Murder (1966), also feature the inimitable Mother Paul. In Faculty of Murder the nun-detective runs Brigit Moore Hall, a fictitious Catholic women’s college at the University of Melbourne (the tower of Ormond College was on the book’s dust jacket). Mother Paul investigates the disappearance of a college resident and the death of a professor’s wife. In Make-Up for Murder the nun-detective is in charge of Maryhill Girls’ School in Melbourne. Mother Paul investigates the murder of a former school student and the disappearance of a famous TV singer. June stopped writing crime fiction altogether after that.
While having six crime novels published was a great achievement, June hit a couple of literary brick walls along the way. In 1952 Hutchinson rejected her crime novel The Law Courts Mystery, which was set in and around Melbourne’s law courts, because “the readers reported that although your book was likeable, with humour and movement, it was spoilt by the plot, which was unconvincing and rather muddled. Also, the relationship between the characters, even when they have a lot to do with each other, is always too remote and bloodless,” June’s publisher told her. The Law Courts Mystery was never published and the manuscript has now been lost.
On the basis of three critical readers’ reports Hutchinson also rejected the crime novel that June wrote following Reservation for Murder, which was called Duck Season Death. The first reader said: “There are very good features here, but the author . . . has in effect produced a rather stock-box novel of the whodunit house party variety.” In the second reader’s opinion, “if the author had strewn less red herrings around, her mystery would have been less confused and in consequence improved.” And the third reader said: “The mechanics of this story follow the old lines of the ‘country house’ murder, where everyone is suspect and the final denouement highlights the most insignificant character.” However, June’s book is much better and far more interesting than the readers’ criticisms suggest.
COVER PAGE OF THE ORIGINAL TYPESCRIPT
In Duck Season Death Athol Sefton, the publisher of an Australian literary magazine called Culture and Critic, is fatally shot while duck hunting in northern Victoria with his nephew Charles Carmichael, the crime fiction reviewer for Culture and Critic, who then sets out to solve his uncle’s murder by using his knowledge of detective stories. June suggested The Textbook Detective Story as an alternative title for Duck Season Death, and I suspect that her literary guide, the crime fiction reviewer A.R. McElwain, was the inspiration for the character of Carmichael. Furthermore, given Carmichael’s particular occupation, I’m sure that the irony of getting three negative, book-deal-shattering reviews of Duck Season Death was not lost on June—as disappointed as she must have been to receive them.
The good news is that everyone can now read Duck Season Death—albeit more than fifty years after June wrote it. What a marvellous time capsule this book is of everyday life in Australia in the late 1950s, as well as challenging the detective powers of the reader. Let’s hope that in the best traditions of Sherlock Holmes pastiches June’s family will one day discover The Law Courts Mystery hidden in a trunk somewhere in an attic.
DERHAM GROVES
CONTENTS
PART ONE: Shooters and Suspects
PART THREE: The Impossible Remainder
Shooters and Suspects
I
The summer had been an abnormally wet one. From the Fisheries and Game Department of the State Government of Victoria came a bulletin to the effect that duck-shooters might look forward to an excellent season’s sport. Dry conditions in the north had sent flocks of chestnut and grey teal, freckled, wood, hardhead and black duck winging their way south to the lush swamps and reedy lakes scattered below the Murray river.
One of the districts suggested by Game Research officers for the three months of duck-shooting was a radius of fifteen miles centred approximately by the small town of Dunbavin.
About three miles to the northeast of Dunbavin, the country rose out of its swampy bed in a knoll known as Campbell’s Hill. Nearly a hundred years previously, a squatter from the wild cattle district further inland had built on the rise a pseudo–hunting box. He used to retire there to escape the importunities of Her Majesty’s Colonial Surveyors, and to ease his nostalgia for the grouse moors of his homeland by shooting the plentiful wildfowl. Constructed of sturdy stone, the house had outlasted each subsequent owner who had put it to as many varied and unprofitable uses as there were shoddy additions to its original walls. The present owner, Ellis Bryce, had made it into a hotel catering for duck-shooters.
Ellis was a man of unending wild-cat schemes which he took for inspirations of genius. Indolent by nature, his enthusiasm seldom went beyond the initial idea. Having bought out the previous owner of Campbell’s Hill, who had been trying to make a go of rice growing, he satiated his genius by talking the local licensing court into a permit to sell liquor and putting up a hanging sign whose gothic lettering read The Duck and Dog Inn. Then he sat back grandly and allowed his sister, Grace, to do all the mundane toil connected with the running of a country pub.
Miss Bryce was devoted to her widowed younger brother, and had followed him into all his projects, lending the resources of both her energy and her meagre income. She was a faded but wiry little woman, pared down to skin and bone by years of unnecessary bustling and fretting.
One humid, rainy day towards the end of February, Miss Bryce sat at Ellis’s littered desk in the gunroom checking through the reservations for the opening of the season. Her brother lounged in an armchair in the hall outside, occasionally calling out items which caught his fancy in the local newspaper. He enjoyed pointing up the bucolic journalese by reading in a declamatory manner.
“‘A delightful afternoon was had by all at the lovely home of Dr and Mrs Spenser, who opened their beautiful grounds for a Garden Fete in aid of our newly formed and enthusiastic Arts and Crafts Group. Wearing a charming gown of burnt sienna marocain figured with lime green leaves, Mrs Spenser—’”
“Ellis, will you be quiet! How do you expect me to work out the allocation of rooms when you’re—We’ll have the guests arriving and no notion how to place them and all you can do—You don’t seem to realise the amount of work—” Miss Bryce always talked in unfinished sentences, her darting mind in advance of her tongue.
“They’ll shuffle down all right,” he returned easily. “What is a cloche curvette? Mrs Spenser was wearing a smart brown one.”
“Probably her old basin felt, done up,” Miss Bryce replied absently. “Ellis, who is this man, Harris P. Jeffrey?”
“‘Dr Spenser dispensed hospitality with his customary genial bonhomie.’ If his hospitality was anything like the whisky he gave me once, I’d say he dispensed right out of the bottles from his surgery . . . An American, by the sound of his name and the look of the initial. They always seem to have their Christian and surnames the wrong way round.”
“An American!” repeated Miss Bryce uncertainly. “Oh dear, and we’ve only got the one bathroom.”
“So what!” Ellis tried out the phrase distastefully, as though ready to make every concession to the visitor’s