Fiona allowed a shudder to ripple through her.
“The crux of the defense’s case, though, rests on Kimbra’s alleged hatred of the police. Her loathing for authority, they want you to believe, is the real reason for the charges against Detective DeMarco. She held a grudge against him for hassling her on the street so what better way to get back at him than to accuse him of a brutal crime? It’s been known to happen, they warned you.”
Fiona let contempt creep into her voice. “Only one thing wrong with that theory, ladies and gentlemen. Kimbra Williams was raped and beaten on the night of April 17. She didn’t lie about those bruises. You saw the pictures.
“For all we know, she was left for dead in that alley, but even if her attacker never meant to kill her, you can be certain that a man like Vincent DeMarco would not expect her to press charges against him. After all, as a police officer, he would know that fifty percent of all rapes go unreported every year because the victim is either worried she won’t be believed or is afraid of retaliation by her assailant.
“Retaliation is what the defense wants you to believe motivated Kimbra Williams. But let’s examine that for a moment. A girl in Kimbra’s position, a runaway who spends most of her life on the street, falsely accuses a police officer, of all people, of rape. How easy would it be for him to retaliate against her? She’s vulnerable. She’s alone. No friends or family to come to her rescue. Do you really think she’d take that chance?”
Fiona walked back to the jury box and once again placed her hands on the rail, leaning forward. “Vincent DeMarco’s fate is in your hands today, ladies and gentlemen, but regardless of what you decide, Kimbra Williams’s life is never going to be the same. Thirty-one percent of all rape victims develop Rape-Related Post-traumatic Stress Disorder, and they are nine times more likely to attempt suicide. A pretty grim statistic, isn’t it?
“But the most frightening statistic of all isn’t about the victim. It’s about the assailant. Studies have shown that the recidivism rate among rate among rapists can be as high as 50 percent. That means if Vincent DeMarco is allowed to walk out of this courtroom a free man, there is an extremely high probability he will rape again.
“Who will his next victim be, I wonder? That one woman out of three who will be sexually assaulted in her lifetime?”
Fiona gazed at them for a moment longer, then turned and strode back to the prosecution table to await the judge’s final instructions to the jury.
CHAPTER SEVEN
HANDSOME AND CHARMING, with a confidence that Fiona found exceedingly annoying, Dylan O’Roarke had become her number one nemesis in the courtroom since she’d moved to the Criminal Prosecutions Bureau five years ago. Which was only fitting, she supposed, seeing as how their families had been mortal enemies for decades, Chicago’s own version of the Hatfields and the McCoys.
The feud had spanned three generations, beginning in the Prohibition Era when Fiona’s grandfather, William Gallagher, had played Eliot Ness to James O’Roarke’s Al Capone. Once close friends, the two Irish immigrants had become bitter rivals, not only because they’d chosen different sides of the law, but also because they’d fallen in love with the same woman, Fiona’s grandmother, Colleen.
Two recent marriages between the clans, including Dylan’s union with Fiona’s cousin, Kaitlin, had brought an uneasy truce between the families, but as far as Fiona was concerned, the peace accord didn’t extend into the courtroom.
So when he approached the prosecution table after court was adjourned, she glanced up with a fair amount of suspicion.
“Have you got a minute?” he asked her.
She snapped closed the latches on her briefcase and stood. “That depends.” Her gaze slid past him to where Vince DeMarco stood talking and laughing as if he didn’t have a care in the world. “Is your client ready to accept my offer?”
Dylan gave a sharp laugh. “Are you kidding? That wasn’t an offer, it was an insult. Second degree sexual assault and seven years at Stateville? No way my client’s doing any time. He’s walking and you know it.”
She gave him an angry glare. “He’s guilty, and you know it. Kimbra Williams is only seventeen years old, Dylan. How do you sleep at night?”
Dylan’s mouth tightened as he returned her glare. “I sleep just fine. How about you, Fiona? Ever have nightmares about Jessie Carver?”
An arrow straight through the heart.
Jessie Carver was one of the Fullerton Five who’d maintained his innocence from the first. He claimed that one of the other suspects in the case had implicated him in order to cut a deal with the prosecution, and then, after forty-eight straight hours of verbal intimidation, beatings and sleep deprivation, he’d signed a confession out of sheer desperation.
In one of those ironic twists, Dylan had represented Jessie Carver three years ago, and now he was defending one of the cops Jessie claimed had coerced his confession, proving that Chicago politics wasn’t the only profession that made for strange bedfellows.
“I believed Jessie Carver was guilty three years ago, and my feelings haven’t changed,” Fiona told him. “The investigation into the Area Three Detective Division was never about Jessie’s innocence. At least not for me.”
Dylan started to say something else, perhaps to argue the finer points of her logic, but then he shrugged. “Believe it or not, I didn’t come over here to start an argument with you.”
“Yeah, well, that’s sort of a fait accompli when you put a Gallagher and an O’Roarke in the same room.” She picked up her briefcase and started walking toward the exit. “So what did you want to talk to me about?”
Dylan fell into step beside her. “Kaitlin wanted me to remind you about her father’s retirement party.”
Fiona rolled her eyes. “Honestly, how many times do she and my mother think they have to nag me about that?” Between the two of them, they must have called her half a dozen times in the past two weeks. It wasn’t like she was senile, for Christ’s sake.
“She’s worried because evidently you forgot Erin’s baby shower last month, and before that, it was Nikki’s birthday party,” Dylan helpfully pointed out.
“I explained all that.”
“You were busy. Yeah, we all know how hectic your social life is, Fiona.”
Screw you, she thought angrily.
“Look, I know you have quite the progressive attitude regarding family these days, but this retirement party is a big deal to Kaitlin. She sees it as a way to cement her reconciliation with her father, and she wants the whole family together. And in her condition, I’d rather not have her upset.”
“I know it’s a big deal,” Fiona said impatiently. “I said I’d be there, and I will be. It’s next week, right?”
“Fiona, it’s tomorrow night.”
She stopped dead in her tracks. “Tomorrow night? That’s impossible.” Where had the days gone?
“So I guess you did need another reminder after all.”
Honest to God, if he smirked one more time—
“Oh, like you’d even be there yourself if it wasn’t for Kaitlin,” Fiona grumbled. Dylan and his father-in-law were hardly bosom buddies. Liam Gallagher had disowned his daughter when he’d found out about her elopement to Dylan, and had ordered her out of his house, never to return until she came to her senses and divorced that lowlife, scum-sucking