“Maybe, maybe not. But it’s awfully convenient that he was right there.”
“He lives close by.”
“Not close enough to hear anything. And…Claire?”
“Yes?”
He seemed to be struggling with what he wanted to say next.
“Dad?”
He sighed. “It’s so hard to know what to reveal and what not to reveal.”
Claire gripped the phone tighter. “There’s something you haven’t told me?”
“It’s not directly connected to Alana going missing. I’m sure of that. But…I’ve often debated whether it would make things easier on you to know. And now that you’ve asked… I don’t want this eating away at you, sending you down the wrong path.”
“Tell me.”
“You asked about Leanne being out of school for three hours on the day your mother went missing.”
A hard knot formed in Claire’s stomach. His manner worried her. “Yes?”
“That did happen.”
Leanne had just denied it. Initially, he’d denied it, too. “Then why’d you say—”
“The question took me off guard,” he broke in. “I’m so used to protecting her, so used to minimizing the damage caused by that day, it’s become instinctive to lie about it.”
Claire swallowed hard. “I don’t understand. There must be a reason you’d say she was out of school and keep saying it.”
“Yes. And if you’re going to pursue this, you need to know what it is.”
Whatever “it” was sounded pretty ominous. She took a shaky breath. “I’m listening.”
“It wasn’t your mother who was…involved in some way with Joe Kenyon.”
“Who was it?” Claire could barely make herself heard, but she must’ve spoken loudly enough because he responded with the name she’d suddenly guessed he was going to say.
“Leanne.”
“That can’t be true,” she said. “Leanne was only thirteen at the time. If…if Joe was molesting her, he should’ve been punished. Why would you lie to keep what he did a secret?”
“Because he didn’t molest her. What happened wasn’t his fault.”
Claire stared at the carpet, studying the large flowers as if tracing them on paper. “That doesn’t make sense. He was at least seventeen to eighteen years older than she was.”
“But she had a thing for him. You remember Katie, don’t you?”
How could she forget Katie? Her sister’s best friend had been almost as hard to put up with as Leanne. “Of course. She lived next door to Joe until her family moved during her and Leanne’s junior year.”
“That’s right. I guess—” his words fell off but he seemed to marshal the resolve to continue “—I guess Leanne was coming on to him.”
Sickened, Claire covered her mouth and spoke through her fingers. “How does a thirteen-year-old girl come on to a thirtysomething man?”
“I can’t talk about it. I…won’t talk about it. It’s too upsetting to me, and I’d rather keep the unflattering details private, for your sister’s sake. To be fair to her, that was a long time ago, and…and sometimes girls get themselves mixed up in stuff like that when they’re discovering their sexuality. Or so I’m told,” he added in a mumble.
Claire had never even been tempted to come on to a man nearly two decades older, but…she decided to give her sister the benefit of the doubt.
“Just know that she was young and confused and tried to…entice him,” he went on.
“And you’re sure he—” Her throat closed up. After swallowing, she began again. “Did he act on what she offered him?”
“No.”
“He might have done more than you think. Maybe that’s what instigated…her interest.”
“He had proof when he called us, Claire.”
Claire couldn’t help thinking of Leanne in that nightgown. She’d assumed her sister’s promiscuity stemmed from the accident, but this made her wonder if it’d started at a much earlier age. “What kind of proof?”
“A video she made for him.”
Gross… Claire couldn’t bear to think about it. But she still needed the answers she’d been searching for from the beginning. “So…what does Leanne’s being out of school on the day Mom went missing have to do with any of this?”
“It was that morning Joe contacted us with the…news. Your mother was so upset when she heard it, she called me in tears. I’d dropped her off after having a cup of coffee and a doughnut with her, had just arrived at the gun shop, so I asked her to wait until I could get off work, told her we’d deal with it then. I couldn’t leave. I had nobody to watch the store. Walt was out of town and depending on me, and Don Salter, who could’ve replaced me, wouldn’t answer his phone.” He took a moment to gather his thoughts or his emotions or both before continuing. “But apparently she couldn’t wait. She marched down and signed Leanne out of school so she could talk to her before you were home.”
“And what did Leanne have to say?”
“She denied the whole thing. So Alana took her over to Joe’s, and he showed them the tape.”
That was why Leanne had never mentioned being out of school. She didn’t want to admit she’d made a pornographic video at thirteen, which she used to solicit a married man. Claire also understood why Tug had kept quiet all these years. But how had Joe and that tape and Leanne’s behavior affected the investigation into Alana’s disappearance? It must have hampered the sheriff’s ability to do a thorough job with everyone being careful not to say too much about the day in question.
“Why hasn’t Joe told anyone?” Claire asked. “Like one of the investigators you hired?”
“Because he’s a good man.”
If what she was hearing was true, Claire had to agree. He’d tolerated a lot of talk, been convicted of committing adultery with her mother in the court of public opinion, and yet he’d never stepped forward to point a finger at Leanne. That certainly changed how she thought of him.
Now she could explain some of those “inconsistencies” listed in that file. But what did that have to do with her mother’s disappearance? Or were the incident with Joe and the kidnapping two separate items?
“So…Mom took her back to school?” Claire remembered there being some confusion about that in what she’d read.
“No. She was crying too hard. She’d had a terrible fight with Leanne. You can imagine what it must’ve been like after they left Joe’s. So I closed up and took Leanne back to school for her. I thought it might help your mother to have some time alone.”
“When was that?”
“I can’t remember exactly. About one o’clock, I think.”
But the log said Leanne hadn’t signed in until two. “And Mom was…”
“At the house. That’s where I left her.”
“And she was fine?”
“As fine as could