Active management typically generates active risk and active return. Active risk is that risk that causes a portfolio's return to deviate from the return of a benchmark due to active management. Active return is the difference between the return of a portfolio and its benchmark that is due to active management. An important goal in alternative investing is to use active management to generate an improved combination of risk and return.
Active management is an important characteristic of almost all alternative investments. Unlike traditional investing, in which the focus is often on security analy- sis and passive portfolio management, the focus of alternative investing is often on analyzing the ability of the fund to generate attractive returns through active management.
1.7.2 Absolute and Relative Returns
The concepts of benchmark returns, absolute return products, and investment diversifiers have been briefly introduced in this chapter. Let's examine these and other concepts in more detail. In alternative investing, there are two major standards against which to evaluate returns: absolute and relative.
An absolute return standard means that returns are to be evaluated relative to zero, a fixed rate, or relative to the riskless rate, and therefore independently of performance in equity markets, debt markets, or any other markets. Thus, an investment program with an absolute return strategy seeks positive returns unaffected by market directions. An example of an absolute return investment fund is an equity market-neutral hedge fund with equal-size long and short positions in stocks that the manager perceives as being undervalued and overvalued, respectively. The fund's goal is to hedge away the return risk related to the level of the equity market and to exploit security mispricings to generate positive returns.
A relative return standard means that returns are to be evaluated relative to a benchmark. An investment program with a relative return standard is expected to move in tandem with a particular market but has a goal of consistently outperforming that market. An example of a fund with a relative return strategy is a long-only global equity fund that diversifies across various equity sectors and uses security selection in an attempt to identify underpriced stocks. The fund's goal is to earn the benchmark return from the fund's exposure to the global equity market and to earn a consistent premium on top of that return through superior security selection.
1.7.3 Arbitrage, Return Enhancers, and Risk Diversifiers
The concept of arbitrage is an active absolute return strategy. Pure arbitrage is the attempt to earn risk-free profits through the simultaneous purchase and sale of identical positions trading at different prices in different markets. Modern finance often derives pricing relationships based on the idea that the actions of arbitrageurs will force the prices of identical assets toward being equal, such that pure arbitrage opportunities do not exist or at least do not persist. Chapter 6 provides details on arbitrage-free modeling.
The term arbitrage is often used to represent efforts to earn superior returns even when risk is not eliminated because the long and short positions are not in identical assets or are not held over the same time intervals. To the extent that investment professionals use the term arbitrage more loosely, these investment programs can be said to contain active risk and to generate relative returns.
An obvious goal of virtually any investor is to earn a superior combination of risk and return. If the primary objective of including an investment product in a portfolio is the superior average returns that it is believed to offer, then that product is often referred to as a return enhancer. If the primary objective of including the product is the reduction in the portfolio's risk that it is believed to offer through its lack of correlation with the portfolio's other assets, then that product is often referred to as a return diversifier.
1.8 Overview of This Book
The CAIA curriculum is organized into two levels, with Level I providing a broad introduction to alternative asset classes and the tools and techniques used to evaluate the risk-return attributes of each asset class. Level II concentrates on the skills and knowledge that a portfolio manager or an asset allocator must possess to manage an institutional-quality portfolio with both traditional and alternative assets.
Thus, Level I focuses on understanding each category of alternative investments and the methods for analyzing each. Level I also provides an introduction to portfolio allocation and management as a foundation for the more advanced treatments covered in Level II. This book has been written with the expectation that readers have a moderate background in traditional investments and quantitative techniques. In some places, a Foundation Check is inserted to alert readers to particular content that is necessary background for the ensuing material. Readers may find the following sources useful in obtaining background information: Quantitative Investment Analysis by DeFusco, McLeavey, Pinto, and Runkle (John Wiley & Sons, 2nd edition, 2007) and Investments by Bodie, Kane, and Marcus (McGraw-Hill, 10th global edition, 2014).
This book is organized into six parts:
Part 1 introduces foundational material for alternative investments.
Parts 2–5 cover the four categories of alternative investments in the CAIA curriculum by providing extensive introductions to each:
Part 2: Real Assets
Part 3: Hedge Funds
Part 4: Private Equity
Part 5: Structured Products
Part 6 introduces portfolio and risk management concepts central to alternative investments. These concepts are covered from the perspective of both managing a portfolio of alternative investments and adding alternative investments to a portfolio of traditional investments.
Review Questions
1. Define investment.
2. List four major types of real assets other than land and other types of real estate.
3. List the three major types of alternative investments other than real assets in the CAIA curriculum.
4. Name the five structures that differentiate traditional and alternative investments.
5. Which of the five structures that differentiate traditional and alternative investments relates to the taxation of an instrument?
6. Name the four return characteristics that differentiate traditional and alternative investments.
7. Name four major methods of analysis that distinguish alternative investments from traditional investments.
8. Describe an incomplete market.
9. Define active management.
10. What distinguishes use of the term pure arbitrage from the more general use of the term arbitrage?
CHAPTER 2
The Environment of Alternative Investments
This chapter provides an introduction to the environment of alternative investing, including the participants, the financial markets, regulations, liquid alternatives, and taxation. Its focus is on explaining the purposes and functions of these components so that readers gain an understanding of why the investing environment is structured the way it is and how the different components interact.
2.1 The Participants
Participants can be divided into four major categories: the buy side, the sell side, outside service providers, and regulators. This section briefly describes the primary roles of the first three categories of participants; the primary role of regulators is discussed in section 2.3.
2.1.1