Beginning Software Engineering
INTRODUCTION
Programming today is a race between software engineers striving to build bigger and better idiot-proof programs, and the universe trying to build bigger and better idiots. So far the universe is winning.
With modern development tools, it's easy to sit down at the keyboard and bang out a working program with no previous design or planning, and that's fine under some circumstances. My VB Helper (www.vb-helper.com) and C# Helper (www.csharphelper.com) websites contain thousands of example programs written in Visual Basic and C#, respectively, and built using exactly that approach. I had an idea (or someone asked me a question) and I pounded out a quick example.
Those types of programs are fine if you're the only one using them and then for only a short while. They're also okay if, as on my websites, they're intended only to demonstrate a programming technique and they never leave the confines of the programming laboratory.
If this kind of slap-dash program escapes into the wild, however, the result can be disastrous. At best, nonprogrammers who use these programs quickly become confused. At worst, they can wreak havoc on their computers and even on those of their friends and coworkers.
Even experienced developers sometimes run afoul of these half-baked programs. I know someone (I won't give names, but I also won't say it wasn't me) who wrote a simple recursive script to delete the files in a directory hierarchy. Unfortunately, the script recursively climbed its way to the top of the directory tree and then started cheerfully deleting every file in the system. The script ran for only about five seconds before it was stopped, but it had already trashed enough files that the operating system had to be reinstalled from scratch. (Actually, some developers believe reinstalling the operating system every year or so is character-building. If you agree, perhaps this approach isn't so bad.)
I know another experienced developer who, while experimenting with Windows system settings, managed to set every system color to black. The result was a black cursor over a black desktop, displaying black windows with black borders, menus, and text. This person (who wasn't me this time) eventually managed to fix things by rebooting and using another computer that wasn't color-impaired to walk through the process of fixing the settings using only keyboard accelerators. It was a triumph of cleverness, but I suspect she would have rather skipped the whole episode and had her two wasted days back.
For programs that are more than a few dozen lines long, or that will be given to unsuspecting end users, this kind of free-spirited development approach simply won't do. To produce applications that are effective, safe, and reliable, you can't just sit down and start typing. You need a plan. You need … <drumroll> … software engineering.
This book describes software engineering. It explains what software engineering is and how it helps produce applications that are effective, flexible, and robust enough for use in real-world situations.
This book won't make you an expert systems analyst, software architect, project manager, or programmer, but it explains what those people do and why they are necessary for producing high-quality software. It also gives you the tools you need to start. You won't rush out and lead a 1,000-person effort to build a new air traffic control system for the FAA, but it can help you work effectively in small-scale and large-scale development projects. (It can also help you understand what a prospective future boss means when he says, “Yeah, we mostly use Scrum with a few extra XP techniques thrown in.”)
WHAT IS SOFTWARE ENGINEERING?
A formal definition of software engineering might sound something like, “An organized, analytical approach to the design, development, use, and maintenance of software.”
More intuitively, software engineering is everything you need to do to produce successful software. It includes the steps that take a raw, possibly nebulous idea and turn it into a powerful and intuitive application that can be enhanced to meet changing customer needs for years to come.
You might be tempted to restrict software engineering to mean only the beginning of the process, when you perform the application's design. After all, an aerospace engineer designs planes but doesn't build them or tack on a second passenger cabin if the first one becomes full. (Although I guess a space shuttle riding piggyback on a 747 sort of achieved that goal.)
One of the big differences between software engineering and aerospace engineering (or most other kinds of engineering) is that software isn't physical. It exists only in the virtual world of the computer. That means it's easy to make changes to any part of a program even after it is completely written. In contrast, if you wait until a bridge is finished and then tell your structural engineer that you've decided to add two extra lanes, there's a good chance he'll cackle wildly and offer you all sorts of creative but impractical suggestions for exactly what you can do with your two extra lanes.
The flexibility granted to software by its virtual nature is both a blessing and a curse. It's a blessing because it lets you refine the program during development to better meet user needs, add new features to take advantage of opportunities discovered during implementation, and make modifications to meet evolving business needs. It even allows some applications to let users write scripts to perform new tasks never envisioned by developers. That type of flexibility isn't possible in other types of engineering.
Unfortunately, the flexibility that allows you to make changes throughout a software project's life cycle also lets you mess things up at any point during development. Adding a new feature can break existing code or turn a simple, elegant design into a confusing mess. Constantly adding, removing, and modifying features during development can make it impossible for different parts of the system to work together. In some cases, it can even make it impossible to tell when the project is finished.
Because software is so malleable, design decisions can be made at any point up to the end of the project. Actually, successful applications often continue to evolve long after the initial release. Microsoft Word, for example, has been evolving for roughly 30 years. (Sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse. Remember Clippy? I'll let you decide whether that change was for the better or for the worse, but I haven't seen him in a while.)
The fact that changes can come at any time means you need to consider the whole development process as a single, long, complex task. You can't simply “engineer” a great design, turn the programmers loose on it, and walk off into the sunset wrapped in the warm glow of a job well done. The biggest design decisions may come early, and software development certainly has stages, but those stages are linked, so you need to consider them all together.
WHY IS SOFTWARE ENGINEERING IMPORTANT?
Producing a software application is relatively simple in concept: Take an idea and turn it into a useful program. Unfortunately for projects of any real scope, there are countless ways that a simple concept can go wrong. Programmers may not understand what users want or need (which may be two separate things), so they build the wrong application. The program might be so full of bugs that it's frustrating to use, impossible to fix, and can't be enhanced over time. The program could be completely effective but so confusing that you need a PhD in puzzle-solving to use it. An absolutely perfect application could even be killed by internal business politics or market forces.
Software engineering includes techniques for avoiding the many pitfalls that otherwise might send your project down the road to failure. It ensures the final application is effective, usable, and maintainable. It helps you meet milestones on schedule and produce a finished project on time and within budget. Perhaps most important, software engineering gives you the flexibility to make changes to meet unexpected demands without completely obliterating your schedule and budget constraints.
In short, software engineering lets you control what otherwise might seem like a random whirlwind of chaos.
WHO SHOULD READ THIS BOOK?
Everyone involved in any software development effort should have a basic understanding of software engineering. Whether you're